Picard can't match AcoustID of a track, but the AcoustID is added

MusicBrainz Picard
,
1

Hi,

About a month ago I added new version of “Doom” soundtrack and submitted AcoustIDs for all added recordings.

The AcoustIDs are visible in MusicBrainz recording pages, e.g. Recording “At Doom's Gate” by Bobby Prince - Fingerprints - MusicBrainz, but when I scan the tracks in Picard, they’re not recognized by their acoustic fingerprints.

In AcoustID page there is a MBID corresponding to the recording I added, but without the title or disambiguation from MusicBrainz, e.g. Track "e7f91c79-36d2-4407-b3c1-626647795925" | AcoustID.

This looks very similar to a problem I reported a while ago, Picard is unable to match tracks, but AcoustIDs are uploaded. Maybe AcoustID server is out of sync with MusicBrainz again?

1 Like
2

AcoustID scan lookups failing for certain recordings is just a thing. Here’s a list of 42 recordings that I’ve noted can’t be looked up by fingerprint:
(Please edit this post if it’s DDoS’ing the server.)

List
  1. Recording “雪に閉ざされて” by 植松伸夫 - MusicBrainz
  2. Recording “空駆けるハイウインド” by 植松伸夫 - MusicBrainz
  3. Recording “戦い(VS野生ポケモン) (1997～1998-M13)” by 宮崎慎二 - MusicBrainz
  4. Recording “1997〜1998-M71A” by 宮崎慎二 - MusicBrainz
  5. Recording “1997〜1998-M74” by 宮崎慎二 - MusicBrainz
  6. Recording “True Love’s First Kiss” by Harry Gregson‐Williams and John Powell - MusicBrainz
  7. Recording “Concerning Hobbits” by Howard Shore - MusicBrainz
  8. Recording “Only One” by Yellowcard - MusicBrainz
  9. Recording “Pushing Through” by Mudvayne - MusicBrainz
  10. Recording “Canvas” by COOLON - MusicBrainz
  11. Recording “冒険でしょでしょ？” by 平野綾 - MusicBrainz
  12. Recording “Shin Troop” by 中川幸太郎 - MusicBrainz
  13. Recording “倦怠ライフ・リターンズ!” by キョン (C.V.杉田智和) - MusicBrainz
  14. Recording “ピカレスク” by 酒井ミキオ - MusicBrainz
  15. Recording “Blend in” by James Wendt - MusicBrainz
  16. Recording “EXERCISE” by 川井憲次 - MusicBrainz
  17. Recording “モグハウスX” by 植松伸夫 - MusicBrainz
  18. Recording “IMPERIAL PRINCESS” by 川井憲次 - MusicBrainz
  19. Recording “ラッキーチューン” by Anna - MusicBrainz
  20. Recording “regret (D.Gray-man エンディング Ver.)” by 星村麻衣 - MusicBrainz
  21. Recording “Heart Goes Boom!!” by 秋山澪(CV:日笠陽子) - MusicBrainz
  22. Recording “2EM26_EM05B” by 鷺巣詩郎 - MusicBrainz
  23. Recording “カレーのちライス(#8『新歓!』Mix)” by 放課後ティータイム - MusicBrainz
  24. Recording “青春グラフィティ” by ハルカ・マキ・アツコ - MusicBrainz
  25. Recording “Girly Storm 疾走 Stick” by 田井中律(CV:佐藤聡美) - MusicBrainz
  26. Recording “IN THE BUSTING SQUARE” by Falcom Sound Team jdk - MusicBrainz
  27. Recording “LAND OF FERTILITY” by Falcom Sound Team jdk - MusicBrainz
  28. Recording “Listen!!” by 放課後ティータイム - MusicBrainz
  29. Recording “My Soul, Your Beats!” by Lia - MusicBrainz
  30. Recording “集積回路の夢旅人 (Instrumental)” by Oratorio The World God Only Knows - MusicBrainz
  31. Recording “とある日常の光景” by 井内舞子 - MusicBrainz
  32. Recording “自業自得?” by 井内舞子 - MusicBrainz
  33. Recording “打ち止めと一方通行” by 井内舞子 - MusicBrainz
  34. Recording “Everytime We Touch” by Cascada - MusicBrainz
  35. Recording “Unmei♪wa♪Endless!” by 放課後ティータイム - MusicBrainz
  36. Recording “Wreck-It Ralph” by Henry Jackman - MusicBrainz
  37. Recording “Money on My Mind” by Sam Smith - MusicBrainz
  38. Recording “Stay With Me” by Sam Smith - MusicBrainz
  39. Recording “FORGOTTEN DAYS” by Falcom Sound Team jdk - MusicBrainz
  40. Recording “THUS SPOKE AN ALCHEMIST” by Falcom Sound Team jdk - MusicBrainz
  41. Recording “撃破前” by 濱野美奈子 - MusicBrainz
  42. Recording “女神像の調べ “ディンの力”” by はまたけし - MusicBrainz
2 Likes
3

Please enable debug output in the Help > View Error/Debug Log dialog and use scan on the files, then post the complete output here.

In general when Picard can’t find a recording by AcoustID typical causes are:

  • There simply is no AcoustID matching the fingerprint of the files. Submitting the fingerprint usually will resolve this.
  • fpcalc is unable to process the file, e.g. due to the file format or the file being broken in some way. Cases like this should best be reported at Issues · acoustid/chromaprint · GitHub , although the actual fault might also be with ffmpeg.
  • There is some networking error
  • There is some other technical issue on the AcoustID side
2 Likes
4

Hello,

Got similar problems since May:

ex 1: Fingerprints are added but in Picard scan detect them as standalone recordings

image
image743×112 6.35 KB

Release added 1 month ago: Release “Tu rêves, tu rêves / C’est la vie, c’est l’amour” by J.R. Dan - MusicBrainz

Looking on the AcoustID page from one of the track, it is linked to MBz but show “DB Key” instead of Recording name

image
image905×83 5.19 KB

ex 2: Fingerprints don’t link to recordings (even after weeks) and so scan doesn’t work in Picard
Release: Release “สิบหกปี แห่งความหลัง” by สุรพล สมบัติเจริญ - MusicBrainz
(and same issue for the ~170 releases here https://musicbrainz.org/series/33763f56-2a41-4cc3-9c28-62d6b51e6c53)
The AcoustID page is created but no link to MBz, it appears in “Additional user-submitted metadata”

image
image901×236 8.82 KB

Did I miss something?

edit: Rescanning all those 170 Thai releases there are actually some where:

(and all the remaining 155 remain not detected at all)

5

I guess MusicBrainz schema change broke the data replication to acoustid.org again.
2020: https://community.metabrainz.org/t/acoustid-linked-to-musicbrainz-recording-but-data-from-mb-not-seen-in-acoustid-page/477842/4
2021: https://community.metabrainz.org/t/picard-is-unable-to-match-tracks-but-acoustids-are-uploaded/544739/2

5 Likes
6

@lukz Is data replication from MB to acoustid.org working? See above^^

2 Likes
7

Not sure if the log request was directed at me, but here’s one example:

Log 
D: 22:05:35,742 acoustid\__init__._run_next_task:252: Starting fingerprint calculator 'fpcalc.exe' 'F:\\Music\\Mainstream\\Various Artists - Disney\\(2009) The Essential Disney Love Song Collection\\08 A Whole New World.flac'

D: 22:05:35,928 acoustid\__init__._lookup_fingerprint:171: AcoustID: looking up the fingerprint for file 'F:\Music\Mainstream\Various Artists - Disney\(2009) The Essential Disney Love Song Collection\08 A Whole New World.flac'

D: 22:05:35,928 webservice\__init__.post:591: POST-DATA 'meta=recordings%20releasegroups%20releases%20tracks%20compress%20sources&fingerprint=AQADtMmkRYmisPB5-Dh-HAcg_nhx5Me_Hs9xkTB1lMLPII8OuceP0FJ1NJuWCU_24PiNfppx1MZ1PDnahSuaI8edHP2h--iO9mhO_PhxPcN7GkftQGTCoxdx_Hh9HM-OT-g18dCiHj9u5AweCXuifMhFDqfwQt2RtXB1PMdDsJRxj_CxO8gf_EF_WA90-ESOw3sRXschHxfCUFqGkjROPahXI813fDpcKfgoKehJ_NBNvAi9o3lU5OKFJ4L25AiTO7iO_3CPB7lOQeeDdAx1tHDEBv7RR3iZ432wRzkY5lnQ7OBPHLGzCsmbo-SPZvnxYl8I98eTHT-RZ4mgJSlCUVJy5EnCBSeE_HjUNPis4irqIMzLQ31kRH0S3EkGPsdJIXQaKMvCIg-DJpJwIbmmI5-GaovSLGjmJzh6InV-JM4VmKwYvMfbEy6mD_3QXEF24g8U90KcEzWuhQ3cET1xBEddNJESDY8eRObRLwH14Ye3JkP4zNCD-Dis8Xik48NBHxtyBu-xC52jHE2zZIZ0XEbDI_wRnkfT7cIb5YIU8zgZROcEcy3KL4jRvA-6H3WUHFq6ZdHwfMF8_GiOiuIT7Nmgc8FDhPnQp3i2B000c-iP40c_-Ci342lW3NeGJG6ZIO_R5GD84yeukME9PE_EoBm_EcyN8CmSf_CSiEMpH7srXBF849LxSNKY4Ysi4ZGOZjz6H326oTmFMw2-ZLWQB8lSHeV-PLuEbzx6Go6Pice3JPkRLlo6SEka5LKx53hGXMSTo3Rgqk9Qnkqw_3jwR2Cfoj2mrKmC_8hNQeQY5Bl-_FJw7nhGTE-P5kNuaE-Rf6iyXLgk9niWIX0W6EeOK8WjnMY_40dsCs8HaNl3lCmmzzrSHv3xDX_Q4s_ho1qCXFty6MOPN4mWxLiMO8GeElqCUNGK0sd29EvRPI8xMW3xVgp4_eCDSDmhXUF-NOvRRw7aBE2N_8hv6M2FfNqkoLmOWjwefjiZqMWP8I_QPBn0Cpey8GioSCh1RFfwungfVGi-D9eIhyyiQ0P64E6Enjj-Hc2ZBBV1PAnxIdeQZMVzCQ8IRtZhLUoSTIkSXzhzJMh_uCmPmEsUXG2hJ8eH2A9q5egb4Ay8TDoeJQ0uHb-E0Tl4Dd1-JF8YI3OUazgZNM-PPzF4HY-I83hw5FTwOIb2ZIYaDUeYIw9uq2DuBz0DPTiPvuBM_HA4HEcmHvmh7HiOmDmer4CvoxaqwokiHU-PHNujbIJ4LcUTZOPQJMdHHA3aE9WP1UVFJlsQXVNCcRAnPch-3IfVRxilu3ia4sOfeEMehlA7vnieINmDK0kOq0F16rjwCz-u7EKeiDF0E1qeo5cR3RueLwiZK5EELdGP7EpEuErA50F5NFzwXgid8EiiVD36REfz4GdwfUJyHuFrNMWzYdcoNOvRaeqGE_EPMYwWRFeK46Tg5xlOGZ8yHj-uKRf-CMklpKe04sZDVAqXoenm41kcnAoiE2z44KQ87MOUyaiWaDrY4yn0LpC_48pwJR2hh0uIElqOPSsuZnh0RF7ygT4u8UGYlYfWHSFvoemi4gsjCjeeFfcMJh9C-UhyHY-W4tZihHmOniFOdXiPRrsQSiQeF81RHw_6MEUyH19O5FGLJ8qx50KT5kF3nFuU48fPGDd45ihzDbXxRzipg8uZwuOSDfnAQ38w8Q6MPlmWoUrJoQmVQ3-Oz0Low9aCWOj24fKg70H9CcdzaDSqt7C2D5V-fMyIM09RO2jCEM8vqFuyDR5Z_ESuLQ_aRCM8HnkDaI5xSgkeo0cY5SlOXAnqI0z-4KSJL9AsNPuOR09CvFdwBfpy2DtyEXdGRXieCjf6oBmPJzbOTEHzoM8c5C-exMkEcTcR_6jTTEbT7fiDZt6I7sF_RP2hJRIVBpmcowdfPAsfnF_AxB_RH_syBn-CRjsiSY2iCFqjxUGW_MFV4yL-Bs1v5IeyZ0foTEHTKahSmfiJH7kpNFRyTOQTxK0lNMke-OMxncGDwD90hQ-eHU3OoPOLPG3xHDmJ92h4J7gzHOJxWPrxZ3COnsV71NByHCF_HP3xfcHjBz_hIzkzI1dyeCNOPsbjpeiJ5jy-48rxLMyDMCF1aE-CXPhx4jv-IPCT4Rn05NAk0viTIp6OYpbQwxUv7Lj54M2La8fDHGdCFQ-DZDryG_9xpSYeBc3RJzmuJ_iDI2mSBDGVMWiOfriS48GOeJ-CpFny4CZe9EHzPAp-NXiWOERyZ0f0HM0lCtWPx7iyB0f-HIl_HM10BW2eGE-IcROugseLK1fwiEfOLFmgKCeDUA8eXMWNvQRvnDj8YUw_5F-gUZJohGkSJbiOonmMn8TlPKimIIyiHThx5cGJ58ilozph6wzeHtdjOMdPpEj247ikB49VnMHViEKTzCEiPTGS4zhNXGyOHV5UqXjCPHizo3mDGj38CA7FC8kUOgxyGQ_6H00lGcd_PEOV8EIT88GZxcGP8gmPXKiTRPgS7EceNJGtEFX24MeNZjL6FD_0DPPxhGjKJ8EvVD7e_FCfHT_6BGF9JJdenIeTE0-H62i-UEJPCscRfkezPnjyQKeJJo5ioY_x40Eu4w8alWmCR0eJcUcu9MwTKMqXGLvU4yb-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&duration=161&client=v8pQ6oyB&clientversion=2.8.1.final0&format=json'

D: 22:05:35,935 webservice\ratecontrol.get_delay_to_next_request:113: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): First request

D: 22:05:35,935 webservice\ratecontrol.increment_requests:138: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): Incrementing requests to: 1

D: 22:05:36,556 webservice\ratecontrol.decrement_requests:146: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): Decrementing requests to: 0

D: 22:05:36,557 webservice\__init__._handle_reply:540: Received reply for https://api.acoustid.org/v2/lookup: HTTP 200 (OK)

D: 22:05:36,557 webservice\__init__._handle_reply:553: Response received: {'results': [], 'status': 'ok'}

D: 22:05:36,557 ui\mainwindow.set_statusbar_message:459: No matching tracks for file 'F:\Music\Mainstream\Various Artists - Disney\(2009) The Essential Disney Love Song Collection\08 A Whole New World.flac'

D: 22:05:36,558 webservice\ratecontrol._out_of_backoff:222: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): oobackoff; delay: 1000ms -> 500ms; slow start; window size 1.000 -> 2.000
1 Like
8

This is the same problem that I’ve been having:

1 Like
9

Hi,

First of all, sorry for the delayed answer, life got in the way. Fortunately @yindesu already provided some logs (thanks!).

I’m using two different Picard versions on different machines and I just checked with both of them.

The old version 1.4.2 is not able to match the recording by AcoustIDs at all:

I: 20:30:15 Plugin directory '/usr/lib64/python2.7/site-packages/contrib/plugins' doesn't exist
D: 20:30:21 Debug mode on
D: 20:30:24 Drop target = <Cluster u'Unmatched Files'>
D: 20:30:24 Dropped the URL: u'file:///home/alioth/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:30:24 Adding files [<File u'e1m1.mp2'>]
D: 20:30:24 Moving <File u'e1m1.mp2'> from None to <Cluster u'Unmatched Files'>
D: 20:30:24 Loading file u'/home/alioth/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:30:24 Updating file <File u'e1m1.mp2'>
D: 20:30:32 Updating file <File u'e1m1.mp2'>
D: 20:30:32 Starting fingerprint calculator u'/usr/bin/fpcalc' u'/home/alioth/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:30:32 AcoustID: looking up the fingerprint for file '/home/alioth/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:30:32 POST-DATA 'clientversion=1.4.2final0&format=xml&client=v8pQ6oyB&meta=recordings%20releasegroups%20releases%20tracks%20compress&fingerprint=AQAC7VmyT5KSIN6TCV2P4_pxlH6O1BIJ7TJi9_hx_MHRD66WoE9k_EK8H3L4DLFRE41x9QquKkHYjNCq8IiJH79Q-grc40O9CDkPXYgvotMa3MeNbX6GLyMiPSv0DpWO_EdVDzd-ox-aSZHwqcORVI-QH0cpHQ2T6fiTII8PnYqQD8fpDeeDKpMO_7iEXluQ59B35MH4HS_RJtwCx0ceGX1W3NCx8og3HTstNE-OPsKFM0bsXJCP-OjRVMJFZ4h0PYEeBnmOH1WED31s2Dvx6agXHTkPHfmNu1hnobIO_0P4E7pS7EuH-Lj04vrxoY8Ed0TJ0XiP00d-qM-FXKGO-tj4EDWPS2aQazt0ITya53jx8HgXo8f2IyehGTf6dAizpwh_-MYb4coEj3D-odJSH9c6ovji4MqOn0dzhsQbpTF6PMNzXLDuQCd8_EH6Ff3RH81zvAgzicEL8Uan1eiP88Bz-DG0Rjl6Gn55OA7alUHlED6PKwvM8XhkolFpPEsHHbWkBzeLi4WPXjR0fEf4wzk_3CK-CMePJ0feQz_ScIqPjzhzXEO5hPjRTdmR8MoROyXKrMd74UfPozl-lI0XpDy-QSR5PPg0nDXa4wuXot7hQ3xgHRXyLFHwo76D9HhGQmfRH6H0HfZgckep4TzCSzkS_viD9hneFPfQPA5q4j_CHrrw44evqDiPRpOGz2hOaGeE__izoS9-3NB7_HBX4dXwQ_zw9Mi9xmiYC8_RPBn6RAhlHQ1HqEezVziz49qSoseNz2i64x4z-BCfPQifGt9zNJ2CnujRcL1wWggj77jh8_gLkUZPo3_wEX-Hy4HYLe7QD82PPvzwHg1R-9CCw1yOizp8Nrh-iIeZkQp65MrRw8-OFz5rXBGFCz6PR9kl_MeLwz8RimrQB9fx5vB6lFKhR0Hlo5GqICePK0el9TBX48dHhJ6OmzO0a3h8vMHFQLwu9KhF8cgXorKKZwh3HT7HQD_MKEgvvEVKMrjwa_h-tHtEfEfZGd5xRThD4uWNdtlxl0eN5kXhh4djo1MUOdBu-Ic5Hn2C_yhFwWfwQw_SPIe3Hk8eYY-O__Bl9EVkMk2h_sj7DhVX2NHR77gXhB0PPYly5PjR_Ti-Hc2FWsIXBvkeJDkqeccnHr_xPEJ-YRsZ6EqOCvnxG990ZWi-DkeP58ibQicpRMRPoimJ8jn-B_lz_IGmL8hHdMeb4-ox5Tx6EZ-Md_gR0a0gI_zxHX7Q42aOL0c4pYd-5B9OFz-OaIdufCtSWnhewf_QI_ShBWGWWyi7Bu_QoHuYIX9RViNcB0d_I0cYTTt6Bv_Qw99hHo4qoT4eNMplfNnhE4f456g3NOfRjiH66IP1EI7Q96jFQxxZfKTR7PFwNEdv9GngKhOFEz58hLs9hKmLXoZ65WjqHGWH6vCl43_haSTuQ8-L3TpyBch1lAyJ6tj-QOMzokcTbrhSNO2FaiuOHm02FT-6H1rODI9w9KiF_vCHHs0TfBClGJ2XDb1gbcQPXUMrBv-C8Ic74ibSX3jDw7cI_XDRE4179D0KLSIfaBea7jiPZqwhN8ePH21UnOLQnMc3HSKewh139NKh6Wj0TMhxZ0afwDv84xqP-8ghjnnRFXmJPrBa-BLCH2V7aGE2nEe44xnO8DhzpCfeHO6O6mHQUOgrhE_xHI-IPkflHc2DZxauI0zFG7IzRod5-Oij4qi3Iz9-pEet0IWO5uhzhNF0tAt6GunxGVoe9KuEV8WhG82L-CeuH82PKzDX4FFumP_QMz6eqAgP93g64lkQH3_QN_hwpxvaX2ge_MEfhCoTdM2gC-HDownxoye2o5qHH_fRiEeo46IO7YeWZ8WnSZi8Fw-Px3h2nIJG7jguXdCsHd7x78grdNvxo8_RPFOL8D-Sk2i5GI-Gw_fwE7-KMI-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&duration=95'
D: 20:30:32 WSREQ: First request to ('api.acoustid.org', 80)
D: 20:30:33 Received reply for http://api.acoustid.org:80/v2/lookup: HTTP 200 (OK) 
D: 20:30:33 AcoustID: Lookup successful for '/home/alioth/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:30:33 No matching tracks for file '/home/alioth/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:30:33 Updating file <File u'e1m1.mp2'>

The new version 2.7.3 is recognizing the recordings, but it displays them as non-album recordings. This is incorrect, because they are assigned to an album. I guess that’s the same problem @ulugabi has seen:

D: 20:32:28,925 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/tagger.add_files:575: Adding files [<MP3File 'e1m1.mp2'>]
D: 20:32:28,926 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/formats/id3._load:244: Loading file '/home/alioth/Doom/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:32:28,926 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/config.event:254: Config file update requested on thread 139628463781696
D: 20:32:29,398 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/file.update:707: Updating file <MP3File 'e1m1.mp2'>
D: 20:32:29,398 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/file.move:615: Moving <MP3File 'e1m1.mp2'> from None to <Cluster 'Unclustered Files'>
D: 20:32:37,148 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/acoustid/__init__._run_next_task:252: Starting fingerprint calculator '/usr/bin/fpcalc' '/home/alioth/Doom/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:32:37,322 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/acoustid/__init__._lookup_fingerprint:171: AcoustID: looking up the fingerprint for file '/home/alioth/Doom/e1m1.mp2'
D: 20:32:37,323 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/__init__.post:591: POST-DATA 'meta=recordings%20releasegroups%20releases%20tracks%20compress%20sources&fingerprint=AQAC7VmyT5KSIN6TCV2P4_pxlH6O1BIJ7TJi9_hx_MHRD66WoE9k_EK8H3L4DLFREzZR6gquKkHYjNCq8IiJH79Q-grc40O9CDkPXYgvotMa3MeNbX6GLyMiPSv0DpWO_EdVDzd-ox-aSZHwqcORVI-QH0cpHQ2T6fiTII8PnYqQD8fpDZceVKkO_7iEXluQ59B35MH4HS_RJtwCx0ceGX1W3NCx8og3HTstNE-OPsKFM0bsXJCP-OjRVMJFZ4h0PYEeBnmOH1WED31s2Dvx6agXHTkPHfmNu1hnobIO_0P4E7pS7EuH-Lj04vrxoY8Ed0TJ0XiP00d-qM-FXKGO-tj4EDWPS2aQazt0ITya53jx8HgXo8f2IyehGTf6dAizpwh_-MYb4coEj3D-odJSd7jWofji4MqOn0dzhsQbpTF6PMNzXLDuQCd8_EH6Ff3RH81zvAgzicEL8Uan1eiP88Bz-DG0Rjl6Gn55OA7alUHlED6PKwvM8XhkolFpPEsHHbWkBzeLi4WPXjR040f4wzk_3CK-CMePJ0feQz_ScIqPjzhzXEO5hPjRTdmR8MoROyXKrHiv40fPozl-lI0XpDy-QSR5PPg0nDXa4wuXot7hQ3xgHRXyLFHwo76D9HhGQieLHqH0HfZgckep4TzCSzkS_viD9hneFPfQPA5q4j_CHrrw4yd85TiPRpOGz2hOaGeE__izoS9-3NB7_HBX4dXwQ_zw9Mi9xmiYC8_RPBn6RAhlHQ1HqEezVziz49qSoseNz2i64x4z-BCfPQifGt9zNJ2CnujRcL1wWggj77jh8_gLkUZPo3_wEX-Hy4HYLe7QD82PPvzwHg1R-9CCw1yOizp8Nrh-iIeZkQp65MrRw8-OFz5rXBGFCz6PR9kl_MeLwz8RimrQB9fx5vB6lFKhR0Hlo5GqICePK0el9TBX48dHhJ6OmzO0a3h8vMHFFOJ19KhF8cgXorKKZwh3HT7HQD_MKEgv5C1MMrjwa_h-tHtEfEfZGd5xRThD4uWNdtlxl0eN5kXhh4djo1MUOdBu-Ic5Hn2C_yhFwWfwQw_SPIe3Hk8eYY-O__Bl9EVkMk2h_sj7DhVX2NHR77gXhB0PPYly5PjR_Ti-o7mKWsIXBvkeJDkqeccnHr_xPEJ-YRsZ6EqOCvnxG990ZWi-DkeP58ibQicpRMRPoimJ8jn-B_lz_IGmL8hHdMeb4-ox5Tx6EZ-Md_gR0a0gI_zxHX7Q42aOL0c4pYd-5B9OFz-OaIdufCtSWnhewf_QI_ShBWGWWyi7Bi-ao3uYIVeLsjpcB0d_I0cYTTt6Bv_Qw99hHo4qoT4eNMplfNnhE4f456g3NOfRjiH66IP1EI7Q96jFQxxZfKTR7PFwNEdv9GngKhOFEz58hLs9hKmLXoZ65WjqHGWH6vCl43_haSTuQ8-L3TpyBch1lAyJ6tj-QOMzokcTbrhSNO2FaitqHG02FT-6H1rODI9w9KiF_vCHHs0TfBClGJ2XDb1gbcQPXUMrBv-C8Ic74ibSX3jDw7cI_XDRE4179D0KLSIfaBea7jiPZqwhN8ePH21UnOLQnMc3HSKewh139NKh6Wj0TMhxZ0afwDv84xqP-8ghjnnRFXmJPrBa-BLCH2V7aGE2nEe44xnO8DhzpCfeHO6O6mHQUOgrhE_xHI-IPkflHc2DZxauI0zFG7IzRod5-Oij4qi3Iz9-pEet0IWO5uhzhNF0tAt6GunxGVoe9KuEV8WhG82L-CeuH82PKzDX4FFumP_QMz6eqAgP93g64lkQH3_QN_hwpxvaX2ge_MGPUGVidM2gC-HDownxoye2o5qHH_fRiEeo46IO7YeWZ8WnSZi8Fw-Px3h2nIJG7jguXdCsHd7x78grdNvxo8_RPFOL8D-Sk2i5GI-Gw_fwE7-KMI-hkzhRi0ZPNMYlKui0HuIz6KSwpWFwBdRxM8TEdjMAAgwJQiAgjBAGEOGBIAgAopgTBEhBmDDaIAEAI0gA4igRwHgHKFDECSgIUYAoQwUhjAijBBCIKWCJAEYQxIgx2ghhFAWeMMCAEsYTAIwBAjDghQPCYWAEAcwAIRgSRAjBiCHECKIFEVgIAhURhiiHoEAECMyMcEZQhARBTACECCDEAQaNEQAAgABjDAhlAHFQCSCooVAwohAyxAnEqIBEEEAAIQ4LIBGQhECCEBKCMACcQQUBJoQQlgBABCIKASeIMQQQ5oAAQBEgjADAQCRAAUIAxiASBAhCBCHOEASIMggQAZwAACDgkADCOMGYEIIAaxAAjgDqDGRACIAkEAYIA5gDCCmggEFCMOQEFUoCAQxDwIDAGAICCqKcMMgIIixETBAFDABGCQuQQwAIaQwgDABLAAPWCCCAAI4YpgAGAlBkHDEOCAGIMk4IoIUgQAhpjFJAEEAAEE4AAwwhQDAEFEDWGaUAowowgwAEijmqDJJCCESYFYgRCVgTXggAmAAAMGAIYMIAIIQhAggAEHCKIEAQAMAIIIQADBmAjEECIGGMUEwQAhhlSAiOnLLIAKAAQEAggKAQQggFiHJCCyIEAkgBQQxRAAnAiACIACWEgoAQwpghBjBAjALMGEEIYowQwARyAkqnAFJCEQEcIogcioASRgnECFBCMAaVIYgABABAziDngWCIAKYQEZACIgQwglAmqEECKYKMQIgRJYAgAAiQECDCKEYcAgAhAA&duration=95&client=v8pQ6oyB&clientversion=2.7.3.final0&format=json'
D: 20:32:37,327 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol.get_delay_to_next_request:113: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): First request
D: 20:32:37,327 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol.increment_requests:138: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): Incrementing requests to: 1
D: 20:32:38,341 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol.decrement_requests:146: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): Decrementing requests to: 0
D: 20:32:38,342 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/__init__._handle_reply:540: Received reply for https://api.acoustid.org:443/v2/lookup: HTTP 200 (OK) 
D: 20:32:38,343 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/__init__._handle_reply:553: Response received: {'results': [{'id': 'e7f91c79-36d2-4407-b3c1-626647795925', 'recordings': [{'id': '532406be-217e-40e8-842b-3b3f6d53610e', 'sources': 1}, {'id': '9658db14-47b4-4359-8751-594ab64dd601', 'sources': 4}], 'score': 0.919463}], 'status': 'ok'}
D: 20:32:38,343 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/acoustid/__init__._on_lookup_finished:128: AcoustID: Lookup successful for '/home/alioth/Doom/e1m1.mp2' (recordings: 2)
D: 20:32:38,344 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/ui/mainwindow.set_statusbar_message:469: File '/home/alioth/Doom/e1m1.mp2' identified!
D: 20:32:38,345 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/file.move:615: Moving <MP3File 'e1m1.mp2'> from <Cluster 'Unclustered Files'> to <Cluster NATS '[non-album tracks]/Unmatched Files'>
D: 20:32:38,351 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol._out_of_backoff:222: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): oobackoff; delay: 1000ms -> 500ms; slow start; window size 1.000 -> 2.000
D: 20:32:38,690 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol.get_delay_to_next_request:118: ('musicbrainz.org', 80): Last request was 55930 ms ago, starting another one
D: 20:32:38,691 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol.increment_requests:138: ('musicbrainz.org', 80): Incrementing requests to: 1
D: 20:32:39,316 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol.decrement_requests:146: ('musicbrainz.org', 80): Decrementing requests to: 0
D: 20:32:39,316 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/__init__._handle_reply:540: Received reply for https://musicbrainz.org:443/ws/2/recording/532406be-217e-40e8-842b-3b3f6d53610e?inc=artist-credits+aliases+artists: HTTP 200 (OK) 
D: 20:32:39,317 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/__init__._handle_reply:553: Response received: {'aliases': [], 'artist-credit': [{'joinphrase': '', 'name': 'Bobby Prince', 'artist': {'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'type': 'Person', 'aliases': [{'name': 'Bobby Prince', 'sort-name': 'Prince, Bobby', 'end': None, 'primary': True, 'locale': 'en', 'type-id': '894afba6-2816-3c24-8072-eadb66bd04bc', 'type': 'Artist name', 'begin': None, 'ended': False}, {'end': None, 'primary': False, 'sort-name': 'Prince III, Robert Caskin', 'name': 'Robert Caskin Prince III', 'begin': None, 'ended': False, 'type-id': 'd4dcd0c0-b341-3612-a332-c0ce797b25cf', 'type': 'Legal name', 'locale': 'en'}, {'begin': None, 'ended': False, 'locale': 'en', 'type-id': 'd4dcd0c0-b341-3612-a332-c0ce797b25cf', 'type': 'Legal name', 'primary': False, 'end': None, 'sort-name': 'Prince, Robert', 'name': 'Robert Prince'}], 'sort-name': 'Prince, Bobby', 'id': '0b27f6b8-96db-465e-a94e-5184f63e8fad', 'name': 'Bobby Prince', 'disambiguation': 'video game composer'}}], 'length': 95000, 'first-release-date': '2002', 'video': False, 'disambiguation': 'Doomworld, Roland SCC-1', 'title': "At Doom's Gate", 'id': '532406be-217e-40e8-842b-3b3f6d53610e'}
D: 20:32:39,319 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/file.move:615: Moving <MP3File 'e1m1.mp2'> from <Cluster NATS '[non-album tracks]/Unmatched Files'> to <Track 532406be-217e-40e8-842b-3b3f6d53610e "At Doom's Gate">
D: 20:32:39,324 /usr/lib/python3.9/site-packages/picard/webservice/ratecontrol._out_of_backoff:222: ('musicbrainz.org', 80): oobackoff; delay: 1000ms -> 1000ms; slow start; window size 3.000 -> 4.000

The logs above are for the first track only, I removed the rest for brevity. Logs about other tracks are similar.

The acoustic fingerprints calculated by both versions are similar, but not exactly the same (I guess this is expected, there are different ffmpeg versions on the two machines I tested on). However, after scanning both Picard version show the same AcoustID e7f91c79-36d2-4407-b3c1-626647795925 in the “New Value” column in the GUI.

For the record, most of my music files are recognized correctly in either version of Picard. It’s just the AcoustIDs that I submitted recently that have this problem.

2 Likes
10

Hello,

Have you some updates around those issues?

I tried to upload again (ex: Release “สิบหกปี แห่งความหลัง” by สุรพล สมบัติเจริญ - MusicBrainz) and still not appearing. But strangely it’s working within seconds for a new release I added today Release “Classic Productions by Surin Phaksiri 2: Molam Gems from the 1960s‐80s” by Various Artists - MusicBrainz)

Will test a bit more this afternoon to see if I can understand something around those :slight_smile:

.