I voted no on this, but would like more input about temporary artwork changes (now reverted back to original) to digital releases since it’s an unusual case.
@tigerman325 just did a batch of Edits on Pink Floyd for something similar. A week long sales campaign. (I am just tagging his name here so he sees this… I stuck my other comments in the thread)
I’ll need Edit #134576634 - MusicBrainz to go through so that I can merge the recordings with the original page:
Release “TVアニメ『DearS』オリジナルサウンドトラック” by 長谷川智樹 - MusicBrainz
@TheFanCon - The edits of a track list would not disrupt a recording merge. You can still line up recording merges and all would be fine. It is the recordings that merge.
2 Likes
Oh, right, I forgot…
I filed a bunch of edits to clean up duplication between Venezuelan and Puerto Rican Nelson González. It’d be great if we could get the clean up edits on this instance through: Open Edits for Nelson Gonzaléz - MusicBrainz
After, I want to merge to Nelson González - MusicBrainz, but don’t want to drag the wrong relationships there. (Feel free to file that merge yourself.)
(The Venezuelan Nelson González we’ll keep is this one https://musicbrainz.org/artist/a9df2e0d-c17b-4e26-a6fd-40e2ea83654e.)
1 Like
I’m removing 33 fake releases, many-CD format from bit torrent.
These are making us waste so many time fixing typos and reviewing unverifiable recording merges.
2 Likes
I would appreciate some votes on this merge, so additional work can be done soon.
The incomplete release needs a lot of work, which I outlined in the edit note.
The original editor (a beginner, based on their number of edits) who added the incomplete release added the barcode that matches the 2-disc release, and the artwork that was added later, so I’m fairly sure what I’m doing is the simplest path.
2 posts were merged into an existing topic: Are digital torrent/blog bootleg compilations releases? (asking again)
I’m nervous about my ongoing 33 release removal, about to apply in 20 hours.
More yes/no eyes still welcome.
There are more than double Yes votes than No votes. But still, 7 No votes is a lot.
2 Likes
classical style vs soundtrack, honestly unsure about this but it doesn’t seem wrong to me.
Difference in opinion with another editor about common capitalization variations as artist intent, would like people to weigh in as right now it’s on 0 yes/1 no for both our edits as we’re the only no votes on them.
Edit: Looks like someone (seems mistakenly) voted down both sets of edits. Here’s a filtered version that has mine and the other editors.
My edits changing The → the (English guideline based argument):
Other editors edits changing the → The (artist intent based on semi-consistency argument, I dispute it being artist intent):
2 Likes
I need this to go through before I can do a bunch of other stuff. Thanks in advance
1 Like
Wouldn’t mind some more attention on Edit #135460237 - MusicBrainz , concerning Worldwide for a physical release. Don’t really know what the approach usually is here (for big-selling artists on multinational labels), so entirely possible that the edit is not correct. (More) comments that would help me make good decisions going forward also appreciated of course. 
1 Like