Thank you, that is amazing. I feel stupid for suggesting a feature that already exists, but I am glad that I mentioned it. I suppose I did not notice it because my favorite frequent broadcast mix, Kutski’s Keeping the Rave Alive, has not had someone meticulously enter 740+ episodes, but it does have the necessary entries for the full album versions of releases, with some of them listed as mixes, so I suppose without looking hard into what constitutes a mix, I had assumed this was limited to official released albums that were mixes… I had not put two and two together, lol…
When I went to van Buren’s epic A State of Trance series of broadcasted DJ mixes,I was able to find a diversity of ways it was attributed - for instance, there was the very dissatisfying versions.
The 2023-12-28 ASOT entry for the 2023 Yearmix has a single track whose title is identical to the broadcast/mix name, and ther eare zero details about what was actually played even though the content should have been quite clear as it was the yearmix.
ASOT 90 from back in 2003has an interesting entry: an annotation of the full track list, but the actual tracks listed for the broadcast are just the segment names, e.g. 1. Regular Episode, 2. M.I.K.E. Non-Stop in the Mix, 3. M.I.K.E. Special, 4. Armin van Buuren Non-Stop in the Mix….
And then we have the very well done episodes as they should be: ASOT 710. Here it is the case that the editor has given the complete & full tracklist with the relevant artists. And here is a detail I love: tracks that do not otherwise appear anywhere in the MusicBrainz database are listed here, so that the recording and the artists involved are effectively added to the archive for good. Here the example would be Invisible Touch (Aly & Fila remix) by Bobina.
Then we have the absolute perfectionist editorial entry:
ASOT 1138 has two different mediums - one is just the show title so that ASOT 1138 can be scrobbled as a single unit, and then thefirst medium, which has 55 tracks listed, including individual tracks listed for THE SHOUT OUTS!
A lot of love wen tinto this. Cheers to the editor, oblomovx. I am not sure if breaking up the shoutout segments on a tracklist is much added value, but so much added value around it, lol…I will certainly attempt to begin cataloguing DJ mixes, and through this beginning to fill in some important missing pieces of the Music Brainz library. But I would emphasize that this has to be done carefully & meticulously.
Allow me to reiterate the importance of this in the sense that… There are some tracks that I cannot find any conventional ‘release infrmation’ for on any website, including massive digital stores & streaming platforms. They exist only as blips in a DJ’s mix, either because they were acquired long ago or are exceedingly unique, or either because they were a mashup or an exceedingly unique unreleased track that only made appearances in live sets or a podcast. It is also the case in the electronic music world that bootlegs abound, and they may have once been lovingly stored on YouTube and a variety of platforms, but they are eventually scrubbed.
Regardless, thank you for your clarification. It’s a real game changer for me. I feel foolish for not knowing this. And I also feel like I’ll never have a shortage of things to submit to MusicBrainz, lol.