how to attach cd toc ?


#1

Hi,

I tried to submit an album (2 CD).
Album is from ‘Sash!’ and called ‘life goes on’.

my submission is : https://musicbrainz.org/release/fd5635a4-3797-4f5e-aa6c-ce43decab685

A release group was existing, I tried to merge into.

cd 1 was not recognized (by picard), I imported a previous stub.
cd 2 was recognized by picard wrongly.
it was recognized as cd 2 from that one : https://musicbrainz.org/release/da244c0c-0143-452a-a9f3-382f2f7b4b35
My cd has (9) nine tracks while recognized as only 8.
My cd has track number 3 in more compared to the other release (other data are similar).

How can I attach cd toc to my new release in order to have it recognized (for my cd2) ?

I’m using web interface.
I made research to do that, but I failed.

Can someone explain me how to submit valid data or do the fix (for me) ?

cd1 - cd toc (cd-discid --musicbrainz)
13 150 16435 33180 50567 67130 83695 113277 135267 153935 171862 195642 218797 246082 277077

cd2 - cd toc
9 150 25967 55455 87485 118547 149577 180885 208170 247915 330471

If someone know a simple tool / command to get disc id (on linux debian stretch), I’m interested in.
I check for previously submitted release and disc id calculation looks failing.

I have cds in hand and can run softwares you may ask me.

Regards,
sp31415 (Serge P)


#2

No promises, no guarantees. :smile:

I think that MB uses an advanced form of the toc and calls them Disc IDs.
Have a look at
https://musicbrainz.org/doc/How_to_Add_Disc_IDs


#3

In addition to the link that @mmirG provided, there are a couple of things to watch out for (and have caught me more than once). You might also have a look at:

It is also discussed at:


#4

See ListMyCDs.com’s post in Adding CD with TOC but without physical CD

In a hoped-for future: [MBS-9443] Allow lookup with MBID when attaching DiscID


#5

Thanks for your help.
As a newbie, I was doing the mistake pointed by rdswift.
I’m also surprised about the delay between my submit to the forum and its appearance (because validation was required)
Regards


#6

@sp31415 this place can be really confusing initially. And there are also a number of impatient users out there who love to criticise. So if you get shouted at, ignore them.

We all learn by making mistakes, and then untangling the mess. :rofl:

After a few errors you’ll start to get the hang of this place. It is not as mad as it initially seems.


#7

The views and opinions expressed above are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any agency

:stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye: