What should an album Label be if the back cover and websites are saying 2 different things

#1

what should an album Label be if the back cover and websites are saying 2 different things take Jars of Clay by Jars of Clay as an example on the wikipedia it has it is by Essential and on amazon if you look on the back cover it is Brentwood Music ( Brentwood Music and Essential Records where both under Brentwood Music, Inc. till 2001)


#2

Put all labels seen on the package, cd.
Online websites are not printed on package so they don’t count. :slight_smile:

5 Likes
#3

thought so i’m just trying to clean up some music

1 Like
#4

As @jesus2099 says - Cover is King.

Wikipedia and Discogs next.

Official Band websites, and fan created websites are often pretty good.

Shops are bottom of the heap and rarely to be trusted. Especially places like Amazon when selling second hand CDs as those are often uploaded by random users and not always as well detailed as they should be. Or an alternate release is attached to the wrong version.

I’d put EBay above Amazon.

-=-=-

If you don’t actually have that actual release in hand it is hard to go back and add a label to it. You don’t know how many editions really exist.

The biggest headaches with labels are when an album is 40 years old and constantly popular. With all the changes in the ownership of the various record labels it is not uncommon to see an album move through many labels over the years.

I think some of your religious disks are also suffering in a similar way. The original release label can fold for various reasons and their catalogue be sold to another who then re-issue the CD with a small change to the label on the back.

Or a different label is used to sell in Europe, Asia, etc.

The weirder the source of the label change, the more to document in the edit note.

1 Like
#5

yer i changed all but one because they were all the same year someone had added the album art to one and it was the same album art that was on amazon the artist has changed label now if they were on bentwood music because it was shut down in 2001.

#6

The back cover shown on amazon seems to be partly obscured by a barcode (sticker?) . It may have also have the Essential Records name/logo on it, it’s impossible to say.

When there are multiple releases, make sure you are working with the correct one. The covers displayed on Amazon may correspond to a different release. Sometimes it helps to go look at editing history.

Based on history and annotation, this release was created for the Canadian release on Silvertone records (the linked discogs entry still shows that data). Years later, a different editor added a release event corresponding to the US, Essential Records version. Rather than changing that to Brentwood, I think it would be better to convert it back to the Canadian release (assuming you can figure out which of that data actually belongs to the Canadian release and which doesn’t).

2 Likes
#7

how do i see see the history for an album. i want to that way i can look at the notes on an album but i’ve asked before and only got a vague response

#8

In the right sidebar, in the ‘Editing’ section, look for the ‘Editing history’ link.

2 Likes
#9

thanks i did not see that there and it goes away when you click the edit button :slight_smile:
im putting the albums back to what they were before i touched them from what i sees with a little more research is (according to the wikipedia) thay signed with Essential Records and were later moved to Silvertone records. Silvertone records was the distributor for the album

2 Likes
#10

Discogs even shows some releases that are dual branded as both Silvertone and Essential (see the cover art for: https://www.discogs.com/Jars-Of-Clay-Jars-Of-Clay/release/5655172 for example). That’s an example where multiple labels are appropriate on an individual release.

1 Like
#11

yep thay releasd on both in 1995 but on 2 difrent dates
https://books.google.com.au/books?id=Tw0EAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA9&lpg=PA9&dq=Silvertone+Records+jars+of+clay+Billboard&source=bl&ots=gsUXgR2AN1&sig=ACfU3U0F_vlLQFBx-Cew44tTXdUCNN7o3w&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwi5m5OZwY3iAhUY6nMBHbLOBfEQ6AEwCHoECAkQAQ#v=onepage&q=Silvertone%20Records%20jars%20of%20clay%20Billboard&f=false

#12

In case of label I’d even say whatever is printed on the CD/record label is even more important than the additional information on the cover.

If the CD has a label code (LC) you can simply look it up and eliminate all doubts.

3 Likes