Track listing that doesn't match a disc ID

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007f7d0259c780> #<Tag:0x00007f7d0259c500>

I’m having an issue similar to what was discussed in this thread, this time with this release. However, the issue is a bit more complicated:

  • track 7 should be a completely different track
  • the current track 7 should be track 21, but track 21 is missing completely from the track list

You can see the correct track list here: https://www.supraphonline.cz/album/195633-pribeh-to-nejlepsi/cd

So, the disc ID is correct (my CD has got the same one) and the track listing is incorrect, but the presence of the disc ID prevents me from correcting the track listing. I had the idea to remove the disc ID, edit the track list and then add the disc ID back, but that would take a long time. :confused:

Any ideas what to do in this case?

1 Like

It normally should not be possible to attach a 21-track disc id to a release with 20 tracks. I suspect the interface is busted in this case.

This might have been fallout from a schema change because if you look at the release’s edit history you will not find any edit which adds the disc id.

I would suggest to remove the disc ID, fix the release, and re-add it. If you can collect 3 yes votes you can accelerate the removal process (or maybe an autoeditor can approve this type of edit).

2 Likes

It normally should not be possible to attach a 21-track disc id to a release with 20 tracks.

Yeah, that’s what I though as well :wink:

if you look at the release’s edit history you will not find any edit which adds the disc id.

The disc ID seems to have been added in this edit.

I would suggest to remove the disc ID, fix the release, and re-add it. If you can collect 3 yes votes you can accelerate the removal process (or maybe an autoeditor can approve this type of edit).

I’ll probably do that, yes.

1 Like

Can’t be approved.

There is this trick which requires more work but can be done in a matter of minutes with auto-editor privileges.

The disc ID seems to have been added in this edit .

Ah, not sure how I missed that.

1 Like

Can’t be approved.

Good to know.

There is this trick which requires more work but can be done in a matter of minutes with auto-editor privileges.

Yeah, I think I’ll just open the edit to delete the disc ID.

Edit: there we go: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/69143287

Edit 2: Thanks for all the approvals, everyone. Here’s the edit with the changed track listing: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/69207865

1 Like