Standalone recording "release" date

[chaban]

Related threads:

Clarifying "Release" in a streaming world

MusicBrainz aims “to collect as much information about music as we can”, which surely includes music released on streaming media like YouTube. I’m a fan of a couple of groups like Scott Bradlee’s Postmodern Jukebox and Pomplamoose. They became famous by releasing videos of music performances on Youtube. Releases on physical media like CDs followed after. So, a streaming audio recording or a Youtube video should constitute a Release in MusicBrainz, right? The ‘‘Release’’ documentation doesn’t …

Release or Recording

I have much to do with digital releases. I’m often not sure what kind of ranges are correct. I have a digital album release postet and streamed on bandcamp. One of the tracks is also “released” as video on Youtube through a unplugged session for a radio station. Is that video a release? I read the documentation - but for me it is not totally clear. UPDATE: Assumed both are releases, how are this both connected?

Digital track: standalone recording vs single

I often wonder when a single digital track is a 1-track single and when it is a standalone recording. E.g. on Bandcamp: If it’s just one track (even if the artist calls it a single) it will have a link like artist.bandcamp.com/track/title. If the single has more than one track it will be artist.bandcamp.com/album/title instead. Factors that imo speak towards the track being a single are: own cover art a music video exists (specific to bandcamp:) it can be found on the discography page of the…

Should I use a standalone recording or single for Youtube?

For music that is only on Youtube, when should I add it as a standalone recording and when should I add it as a single? I don’t know what the criteria are for when which is appropriate. The question is mainly for artists that are primarily or exclusively put their music on youtube. The youtube import script from this page does standalone recordings only, so that is what I have been using. https://wiki.musicbrainz.org/Guides/Userscripts But if it is ok to do so, I would prefer to add/convert m…

Legitimacy of Youtube as a source for releases

I’ve been voting on some of the recent edits, and noticed that @Senax has been removing releases due to them only being linked to Youtube videos. Normally I’d chalk this up to a new user not being familiar with our definition of “release”, but I trust @Senax and if they don’t consider that to be valid, I’m a bit less confident. (Admittedly, the second release is a less-than-perfect example since I was able to pull up more significant links elsewhere, but the first still holds.) I get that a son…