Should I undo this edit?

MusicBrainz
, , ,
1

A few months ago I made this (votable) edit. It is a compilation of Greek Disney songs and naturally the secondary type is compilation but I’ve also added the soundtrack type. I did this because it’s an official CD release and it made sense to me at the time to add the soundtrack type. However, I did get a lot of abstain votes (all of them to be exact) and also people on the Discord server told me they would use that type on releases that only feature a single film’s music. So, I thought that if I don’t get any yes votes before the edit closes, I would cancel it. This exactly happened but I forgot to do so. So, I’m asking here, months later, do you think it was wrong of me to add the soundtrack type or should I leave it be?

3 Likes
2

I would have voted no there as that is a compilation of songs from different soundtracks, but the album itself is not a soundtrack of any movie.
Check this edit about the same topic: Edit #106437396 - MusicBrainz

7 Likes
3

Thanks for the feedback. I suppose I should remove the soundtrack type?

4

In case you will, you can link this topic to your edit note for extra informations.

5

https://musicbrainz.org/edit/114380909
I’ve removed the soundtrack type.

1 Like
6

Thanks to everyone who voted for my edit.