Greetings, Everyone!
We have recently been making a few changes to the UX of the MusicBrainz Android App and would love to hear your thoughts on it.
Here are a few snippets of the changes made:
Please find the video demo at
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1I2hOSxvucY-L6z43aCkXwygGUVHe0ylU/view?usp=sharing
If you like the design, do give it a thumbs up and if you have any suggestions to be added or modified, do let us know here.
Thank you!
Are these changes pushed to the app on the play store yet?
Not yet, we are looking for confirmation from everyone if they find them alright 
Probably will be released soon on the playstore if everyoneās fine with it.
cool - couple of points after watching the video
is there a reason why a Blink 182 band animation shows up under the info page when you go to Pink Floyd?
On the artist page, shouldnāt it read Releases instead of just a singular Release in the top menu?
Will Bio fill with linked the wikidata entry?
Have any improvements been made to the release pages themselves? If so can we see?
At first we were trying really hard to be able to display the artist/band pictures there using the Wikipedia api. However due to copyright issues that we might face, we decided to scrap that idea and just show two different animations there, one for a group and the other for a person.
The Releases point makes sense and we might adapt to that.
The bio is fetched from the Wikipedia api.
Sure! The improvements have been made to the releases display and are available in the playstore in the latest release there of 2.2.9
Thank you!
Cool no worries - but still the animation for ābandā is very clearly Blink-182 (it even has a logo 182 on Travisā drum set!) which might still edge into the realms of legal problems.
I thought that all photographs on wikipedia are part of the Wikimedia Commons and are thus covered under their license options: Commons:Reusing content outside Wikimedia - Wikimedia Commons
I understand the point you make. If you could suggest an animation from lottiefiles.com which would suit a band, I would be happy to change it. 
Checkout IRC Logs for #metabrainz | MetaBrainz Chatlogs ,
you might have to scroll a bit up or down to get the conversation I had with the team regarding the image licensing!
I canāt find a suitable replacement, the website keeps forcing me to sign up which I donāt really want to do 
.
I see, copyright is a real shame and makes things a lot more difficult than they really need to be.
No worries.
Yeah, ikr!
Looks nice
Regarding comments:
PS: Those are āNice to haveā comments, nothing to prevent a release on the store
Sorry to come back to the image again, but why is so much of the screen taken up with a random pic? I thought it might be a āloadingā animation, but the comments here indicate that it just sits at the top?
If so, based off the vid, just get rid of it 
I do have to kinda agree, certainly as I couldnāt easily find an animation of a band that wasnāt the one that is quite clearly Blink-182. I think itād be fine for it to just show the linked wikidata entry
Thanks a lot @ulugabi ! I will take this into consideration and make the relevant changes.
Getting rid of it would make the page look dull with just text.
Thanks for the opinion though!
Do you suggest we merge the releases slide and the wiki data so that it looks neat and serves the purpose as well?
If you want to have more visuals and less text, how about using country flag icons instead of the two-letter country codes? I think this would look neat in the artist search view.
This I agree with. I would want to use the app for information and not loose 50% of the screen to an animation that will get very annoying very quickly. If it was a band image I could understand but the same childish image every time I did a lookup would make me abandon the app very quickly.
As a privacy person I would also be keen to know what type of data is being collected by the app. Any diagnostics of usage patterns?
Also second Kellnerd suggestion about flags instead of country codes.
This sounds interesting. Iāll have a word with the team regarding this.
Thank you!
The point you make is completely valid and I agree with it. Now that everyone is mentioning it precisely, I think we will make the relevant changes.
Thank you!
Definitely worth leaving some space and putting in some imagery!
Iām happy to supply mockups if itās ever helpful. This is what first came to mind:
I wouldnāt even put in the icon since thereās the text that says āgroupā, empty space is always nice. But if there is an image I would use the icons that MB already has to distinguish between groups and people.
