Same album sung in different languages on MusicBrainz

[Fabe56]

Voting/Auto-editor Request Thread

As this seems to be a controversial area (see Same album sung in different languages on MusicBrainz), it would be good to see current community stance: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/62009521 https://musicbrainz.org/edit/62009516

So here we go again, from my side I mostly agree with @chabreyflint point of view.

@chabreyflint

If I see a film, I would say I’ve seen this film, whatever the language. But if I buy the CD, it makes a big difference in which language the songs are sung: these are clearly performed by a different cast, and nobody would argue that different casts for opera or musical would not justify a different release group.

Of course we could (and should) group together film scores without (translated) songs