Requests for Votes Thread

Style / Titles - MusicBrainz doesn’t leave any wiggle room that there should be whitespace and a slash, but it wouldn’t be the only guideline that people ignore around here.

It could also be that other guidelines override this guideline, since the intentional practice by the project leader(s) is not to link guidelines to other guidelines, nor mention which guidelines override the currently viewed guideline.

would like some more eyes on this edit: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90272519

1 Like

There’s a computer game whose music is currently marked as being done by a single artist, but MobyGames has multiple composers listed for the music. Would like some eyes on it if anyone is more familiar with this case than I am:
edit #90326019
edit #90326020
edit #90326021

1 Like

hello everyone!
id like votes on this edit
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90246632
and thoughts on this one
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90246667

@reosarevok , I request your response as Style Leader:
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90271333#note-90271333-7
https://beta.musicbrainz.org/edit/90326019
https://beta.musicbrainz.org/edit/90326020

I need approval of adding a missing track in https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90335516 so I can make the rest of the needed corrections to the release.

I have recently joined the site, and as my first big contribution am updating Sound Souler’s discography and artist page. I think it might be pertinent or someone to look over it just to make sure.

1 Like

Could I please get some votes on these updates?

https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90392609
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90392601
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90392645

Tracks are missing for CD 2 & 3, which in turn led me to accidentally attach the disc ID of CD 2 to CD 1.

i need help fixing the events for a release that is only available in the uk, ireland + overseas territories. this is because in other countries it is released under a different record label.
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90240270

can someone pls approve this for me? editing my own release because my stupid distributor has been so slow recently and the release was approved too late
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90454524

1 Like

I’ve opened some edits to clean up the only release contained in that “Artist”:

1 Like

I made a bit of a mess when adding a release and linked the wrong artist (I blame the heat). I did some other clean-up edits while I was at it.
They’re all for the same artist:

Would appreciate some votes/approval on these!

EDIT: thanks!

1 Like

Any fans of Chris Carter’s “Millennium” TV series here? :slight_smile:

I want to fix this fan tribute to Millennium, which right now is incorrectly attributed to Mark Snow. I just need to have the release group change done quickly, before the empty new release group I created gets automatically removed: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90591585

With the empty RG, just find a link to attach to it. Give it some data to look at and it will not disappear. Got an IMDB link? A fan discography? I think the “empty” state is left in place for a week anyway so that should be plenty of time for you to fill it with a release or two.

2 Likes

Now that I looked at this new empty RG again, the message that the empty RG is going to be removed disappeared. Probably because it has an edit pending. So no problem here, sorry for the noise.

2 Likes

I’m trying to remove a computer game stored as an empty music release in https://musicbrainz.org/edit/90909724 which has been voted against by the original editor.

Let’s just say that computer games that aren’t Mixed Mode CDs are definitely not the reason that the ability to create empty releases was requested.

You can just tag me you know :grin:

Yeah, I’m pushing the boat preeeeeetty far out with this one so I’m not holding much hope, but I’m sick of VGM being an absolute disaster at MB. Interested in any input. That ticket that’s linked in there should have some more eyes on it as well.

I already tagged you in your original edit, specifically citing the Style Leader, so here we are.

Here is a release title edit I would like more reviews on.

Because I am against but there are no other reviewers, so it could feel a little bit unfair arbitrary nitpicking.

The release has a different title on spines, on CD label and on removable obi.
It has no title on cover.

The edit is renaming from spine title to CD label title.

I voted no because I prefer a title that is visible from outside packaging, especially visible on shelves.