Request for votes

Hello voters,
I would need some additional reviewers ā€” and eventually a missing yes vote if you agree with my release event edit:

https://musicbrainz.org/edit/43296402

Europe 2013-09-02 ā†’ 2013
France 2013-09-16

  1. A release date was set to this release as Worldwide 2013-09-02, citing (without linking) a UK Amazon page.
  2. Then it was changed as Worldwide ā†’ Europe 2013-09-02, referencing a USA Amazon import page.
  3. Unaware of this history, I came in with my release in hands and spotted a problem with release event and removed the European date (canā€™t be released same day throughout all European countries) and set my French release date by referencing a crossā€checking website duet (this edit in question).

Maybe 2013-09-02 is the UK release date.
I think maybe but itā€™s not my problem, Iā€™m just editing what I have in hands, removing mistake from Europe. If later additional UK release event is added, Iā€™m happy but it would not be my job.

Same question here, could you vote for my changes to clean the mess

Sorry @kellogsbrainz, I didnā€™t know enough at all to understand those edits, that are now hopefully applied, anyway. :slight_smile:


I come back to this topic as I got a no voter who didnā€™t comment their vote and who doesnā€™t seem to be replying to my questions after 24 hours.

I will wait a little bit more as I myself donā€™t read my emails everyday but I would certainly feel relieved if I could stop checking the status of those 5 edits every now and then, if I could get a second yes vote by someone who agrees with my edits:

Replacing, in a Japanese release, FULLWIDTH TILDE (incorrect match for JISā€™ nami dash) by WAVE DASH, member of Chinese Japanese Korean (CJK) Punctuation unicode block and correct match for their usual nami dash JIS punctuation ę³¢ćƒ€ćƒƒć‚·ćƒ„.

Search for five edits voted ā€œnoā€ by ____, created by me on 2017-02-20


Update

Thanks for your vote @221bbs and thanks @otters61 for your vote before request. :slight_smile:
Still no news from @Jevo.

Sorry, but I had not checked my email. I have added a note explaining why I voted no.

Hi @Jevo, great to see you do receive your e-mails and review them. :slight_smile:

Hello again. :slight_smile:

I have a TYPEWRITER APOSTROPHE to APOSTROPHE edit that was no voted and would be thankful to receive more reviews:

Edit #44265456 - MusicBrainz
Girlā€™s Day ā†’ Girlā€™s Day

I have an edit that was downvoted because I decapitalized the extra title information on the tracks (Aviators Remix -> Aviators remix) ā€“ their argument is that the official tracklist has the words capitalized, but they havenā€™t yet responded to me pointing out that the style guide recommends against title case. Unless that part of the guidelines is out of date, mind tossing a couple ā€œYesā€ votes that way to help the edit pass?

Could I get a second opinion on this edit please. Iā€™m pretty sure there is a strong case for the edit, but I am interested in what others have to say.

ā€œvsā€ vs. "vs."
Hi yā€™all. Could I have some feedback on this edit please.
Iā€™m pretty certain itā€™s a typo or missing the dot. The back cover seems to be nowhere found and lacking this I guess itā€™s up to terms of consistency and taste in unlocking the dispute.

Runnin/Runnin/Running
Hereā€™s another dispute edit
"Runninā€™ by Doman & Gooding feat. Dru" <- I always see this track having an apostrophe (and performing a search in Db confirms this), and again not having a back cover to justify one case or the other, what should be the case here?
Ohh, also the negative vote on the medium here

Last request of the day:
Medium title 1
Medium title 2
Medium title 3
Thanks guys :wink:

Both are perfectly acceptable - one is more commonly British and one American. If you donā€™t have the cover and as such no proof that itā€™s not as printed, why change it? This applies to most of the stuff youā€™ve asked about, really.

3 Likes

Iā€™d like to request some additional votes for Inspired

Edit #45932094
Edit #45932093
Edit #45932092

This involves a digital release, with unmixed tracks and some continuous mixed (DJ-mixed) tracks. Iā€™m trying to set the artist from Various Artists to the DJ-mixer, Tommy Trash.

edit:
culinko has started a thread based on this request:

I could use some feedback on https://musicbrainz.org/edit/46046865

The point of contention is that Iā€™m removing the release event ā€œJapan, 2005ā€ from a pseudo-release. Itā€™s my understanding that pseudo-releases shouldnā€™t be tied to any specific release.

Please weigh in yay or nay.

I wonder, should this topic be merged into Voting/Auto-editor Request Thread ?

4 Likes

can i get some votes on this? https://musicbrainz.org/edit/47567550

iā€™m trying to add the barcode which i used this link https://developer.spotify.com/web-api/console/get-album/ to extract from spotify, but i was voted down before i could explain myself (which i shouldā€™ve did from the startā€¦)
now that i did iā€™m not getting any repliesā€¦ :frowning:

It looks like your edit note sent other editors to 7 webpages looking for a barcode that wasnā€™t on any of them.
That takes some chutzpah!

Can I ask for your votes on https://musicbrainz.org/edit/47668406? It might be the addition of a home-made release. However, I am not sure - thatā€™s why I am asking for your voice.

1 Like

donā€™t need any votes, has been finished

can i get some extra opinions on this edit i have open?
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/51554721