Release lists "Untitled" as the track name. Do we still use "[untitled]"?

I’ve seen my fair share of track listings (both physical and digital) where the word Untitled is literally written on the release. Should all of these tracks be entered as Untitled, or should we still be converting them to [untitled]?

From the official style guideline: Unknown and untitled / Special purpose track title

For untitled tracks, enter [untitled] as the name. These tracks are clearly shown to lack a title on the release (album sleeve and liner notes) they appear on.

The recording and work used for the track will normally be also [untitled], but if the track is given an official name in another release, the recording and work should be updated.

If the track is widely known under an unofficial name, you can use that name between square brackets (conforming to the Capitalization Standard) as track name instead.

For tracks that do not contain songs and that are not named by the artist, you can enter a descriptive name between brackets in all lowercase, or [untitled]. If the track contains only silence, use [silence].

The second sentence in the first paragraph is kind of at odds with these types of tracks, as they’re not technically lacking a title on the album sleeve or liner notes.

I really don’t have an opinion either way, just thought it would be good to hear from folks on the matter.

1 Like

These rules always confuse me.

If the release says “Untitled”, then “Untitled” is the title of the track, not “[untitled]”. Just like we have several artists whose artist name is literally “Unknown” and we file them as such, not as as “[unknown]”.

However, if the track is entirely omitted in the tracklist, then according to the rules it is not “[untitled]” either, but “[unknown]”, because it might still have a name that is just not listed.

So as far as I can see, that leaves “[untitled]” for the rare case when an artist explicitly says “this track does not have a name”. :man_shrugging:

3 Likes

When Untitled is printed on physical release, then it’s the title of the track and we shouldn’t use [untitled]. :slight_smile:

7 Likes

The confusing part for me is that the name of the work, the name of the recording and the name of the track are three different things. A work might be called “La guitarra de oro”, an artist records a cover version and calls it “Die goldene Gitarre”, and later puts the same recording on an LP with a track title “Eine Gitarre aus Gold”, and we usually record all of them. But if an artist intentionally omits a title, we ignore their intent and basically say “but it must have one, we just don’t know it”. In my opinion, even if the name of the recording might be [unknown], the track is clearly [untitled] for me. But I don’t make the rules.

Do you have an example?
Do you mean printed or not printed?

If the track title is not printed, then we use the Work title for track and recording.

If the track title is printed but different than Work title, we still use the track title (including when the title is “Untitled”).
For recording title, it’s not really important IMO, as long as we know the track and work titles. Recording title could as well be an automatic thing.

On a side note, If the track title isn’t printed, but the name of the Work hasn’t ever been given a name outside of the release either, what do we use for the Work title?

Maybe this one: Release “Christus” by Girls Under Glass - MusicBrainz

The CD itself lists only tracks 1–11. I still believe that track 12 was originally not supposed to have a title (it’s not even musical content, just 11 minutes of ominous noises), but when they later re-released the album digitally, they had to come up with something because you can’t have unnamed files.

I have also seen CDs where the cover lists maybe tracks 1–7, then there’s a gap, and then tracks 9–14. In that case I would say that track 8 is actually [untitled] intentionally.

In that example it is called [silence]…

I mean a gap in the track listing where track 8 would have been, not in the audio.

I just don’t remember on which release I have seen that, otherwise i would have posted a link.

It would really be better with a real occurrence, because no need to state rules for ultra-rare stuff.
Random noises, field recordings or improvisations, never replayed the same, don’t require works.

1 Like

As a later official release titled track 12, we can use this knowledge, even for earlier releases, IMO, without brackets because it was not made up by us.

If it’s silence added to simulate side A / side B albums, it can be [silence], indeed.

Ah, sorry, I meant Works that are never given an actual title that aren’t any of the above.

Bands and artists not titling any of their tracks/recordings/works is quite common when it comes to power electronics, harsh noise, industrial, dark ambient, dungeon synth, and especially black metal.

Is this music that isn’t really of interest to the general population? Sure, absolutely.

But ultra-rare? Not at all. There are hundreds of thousands of tracks/recordings/works that are like this.

My OP is answered which is great, so I guess this is all a tangent as alluded to in my earlier reply; I just want to make sure that it’s appropriate to enter [untitled] as the track, recording, and the work when no formal title is given on any of the art, or if I should switch to some other alternative like:

1 Like

For these we can come up with some kind of cataloguing system (between brackets because we are making up those titles), for recording and work names.

It can be numbers, like [album 2 track 3.11], if even the releases have no names. :slight_smile:

And for tracks, it could be [untitled], indeed… :thinking:

See related @maug open Edit #158112493 - Edit medium from Untitled as printed to [untitled].

Yeah, this was the edit I was thinking about when I made my post. I linked the digital release in question in my first sentence but had forgotten to link the edit.

And my now pending CD edition fix edit.

1 Like

Seconding this also! Some artists have a whole slew of untitled tracks which can become a bit much to keep track of. Would be neat with a proper system in these cases.

1 Like

Shouldn’t that go into the disambiguation comment? The recording itself would remain [untitled].

2 Likes

Disambiguating definitely seems like the best choice.

Text between square brackets already means that it has no official title and that some MB editor had to come up with some invented text.

So let’s directly write something useful.