Proposal for New Work Types for Carnatic Music

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007f756ae9b948> #<Tag:0x00007f756ae9b768> #<Tag:0x00007f756ae9b538>

In Carnatic music, different kinds of works exist: Gitam, Suladi, Svarajati, Jatisvaram, Varnam, Kirtanam, Kriti, Pada, Javali, Tillana, Pallavi (Niraval, Kalpana svaras), and Tanam. Just as “Aria”, etc., are provided as kinds of works, these should also be provided as kinds of works.

1 Like

Types of works list is barely a skeleton of what would be needed, even for occidental classical music. There was actually a recent post on this subject.

I guess that the issue is that if we tried to develop a complete list of types of works, for all music genres, we would end up with thousands of them. So not only would we need the complete list, but also a way to structure it so that it is useable by editors.

This is a huge work, especially given that to my knowledge there is no existing “taxonomy” of music works types.

In the meantime, I believe that we may use tags to indicate work types in a way which is simple and effective.

1 Like

While @Algwyn is right that adding all the needed work lists is complicated now, I’d be thankful if you could add a STYLE ticket to our ticket tracker with these works and link for when we have a better way :slight_smile:

1 Like

From what I have gathered from other discussions on the topic of classical music classification, I’m afraid that a structured list of work types is not the right approach.
Especially since composers like to flaunt boundaries, and create works which defy traditional genre, form, etc.

We should rather work on enhancement of the tags system, which provide a more flexible framework. But we should enhance it to have “work types” managed as “genres”.

1 Like