Picard scan still returning new AcoustID submissions as standalone recordings

For many months now, Picard scan has been returning new AcoustID submissions as standalone recordings, rather than matching up to any MusicBrainz Release. What needs to be done to fix this?

Picard standalone recording performance is awful when you’re dealing with more than two files.

5 Likes

I have noticed that too. I thought it was just me.

Just repeated it. Newly added album ( Doggerel )

I went to my tagged files, used MP3TAG to delete the MusicBrainz MBIDs… dropped the album on the left, Scan, and it neatly ID’s on the right as “standalone recordings”.

These are newly ripped FLACs full of the full Album name, artists, the lot. Track names, AcoustIDs - everything Picard added, just with the MBIDs stripped for testing.

Repeat the same test, this time with the correct album sitting on the right hand side as a tempting target - placed by the TAGGER button… still Standalone Recordings.

Very weird. Especially as the copy on the website shows a full set of (matching) AcoustIDs. Uploaded from these very files a few days ago…

Edit: And it is only Newly added albums. Just tried the above test on an album from three years back and scan works as expected and picked a matching release.

4 Likes

I just looked at the acoustid for the first track of your album on Acoustid - Track "674f06c2-4135-499b-9daa-03724acb5ac7" | AcoustID

Notice that although it is linked to MusicBrainz, it just shows the MusicBrainz id rather than the metadata (Title, Artist, Length)

So it seems Acoustid doesnt have an update cache of MusicBrainz (if that is how it works), I wonder if that could that be the problem?

2 Likes

Random guess, but wouldn’t Picard be talking to AcoustID using MBIDs anyway?

I expect you are correct that this will be a delay\update thing. The refresh on AcoustID can be pretty slow to catch changes in the MB database.

It also explains why it slips through testing as it needs a brand new audio source to work with.

1 Like

One for @outsidecontext but maybe it uses the meta information provided by Acoustid, and if Acoustid only returns a recording id assumes it is just a standalone recording.

1 Like

Yes, exactly. AcoustID can return full MB metadata for found matches, and Picard uses this (which avoids an additional request to MB). AFAIK AcoustID uses it’s own mirrored MB database for that, maybe this hadn’t gotten the latest updates yet in this case.

But I guess we could detect cases like this where there is only the recording ID without any other metadata and perform a separate lookup on MB to retrieve the missing data.

I need to see the response AcoustID is returning in cases like this, though. @IvanDobsky could you run Picard with debug logging, scan the file for this AcoustID and share the complete log output here?

1 Like

Okay… this (huge) log is using pre-tagged files. So first steps you will see it load the album, download artwork. Then I drag back over to the left side and Cluster. Then hit SCAN. Resulting in the image as seen.

Log is too large… Will try and turn off all the tags I add… here is a snippet from the end of it for now
Okay - had to give up on that… so I have tried to send the log via email via the main site…
Have randomly chopped and slayed this to get it below 32000 chars… but the full log is in your inbox.
Cheated and tries again - part of different log of a single track of that album… will this be small enough? Yay! Accepted a copy\pasta.

D: 22:12:33,144 acoustid\__init__._lookup_fingerprint:175: AcoustID: looking up the fingerprint for file 'E:\!!RippityRip\+CDs\Pixies\[2022] Doggerel\1-01 - Pixies - Nomatterday.flac'
D: 22:12:33,144 webservice\__init__.post:591: POST-DATA 'meta=recordings%20releasegroups%20releases%20tracks%20compress%20sources&fingerprint=AQADtGSaiIvQLMtS_I3w3EYf4wyHHMmPJvvQmUcTnUHP4sxOODY-5L5gfHTwLEg1Yg9-5UIY9gmYB6pePDq2UsfzBD1r6DvqHN_C4YPQcNmFmsfDHA_OoulRKlJK6JhJWC_yJDyuPOiLTxXcH3VEKULeHYf4sLhp4TyJp0P1xfAv1NCTWQeu8UeNMGKEjzzO44ebSGuQk8IHLa-OzspxHc-qoWfgR4ciZ8d34rrww9qPS3hu9DnSH3X0EN-Rh8ZUQ8sT4S-eIxc7TWjOoz8-nLg24mGGMM-hnbgyHvlx-Bc-onmeoxSVCpcv5PKhOiP8IP8S4mKKrycuPkUTTceDPMGp6IWm4w8ezUj1bPhRKfzgKdpxdfh6NEdO_LiyxNCn5WhyOkaVRcdzD9r_Ib1xbRb6PLjC4YePJ9GcIt-hUzvSCyeuLA2ed_hO-B9isnjGH3oksUH48OhpfGioMEa1GGeuIPyhD4-WHfvRH8d9nMmk4luO7yq0H2EqBg9xBbWuJEbjBJeGY-uJXA90kUe_HGFG4sc353jCHF-EH74QsznOJIoO_YipuMFJwW6M70I57cGD-sgZ_IJ2lOLxJVliIXdqNDl3IfSzQVeQR6E7NG_RX4nwHA_14nvgJ8KnCld4JA-VDGn04MeXp7hT43_Q7EaZ0MdD5CZUZ3mQ55SO54SbZMFF426Q57BC6lC5ZXiSHw3CC7lffEtSnFH0Is6e44U5hsjFFnvy4xf8jEygT8FPeDquB5ek7NCFKUetXMOjJ7iZ4y-s8Bz0ZLi0I7xS9NljnEebBE19PCWqPfC-Im2OWgwP9BaJUsWnPQk-FeoduOOhV8ezIL_QnPFRK6OEa7gKr8f1CNfVIY8SHdpjhMGZfMPVJjj-LhOa6wglZcF36MG_CeeFlBFTHV-S4TzCXkWjnoHuo06O3kF1Es5WoR4uKTlOShr0wxyRizmefDgPW1fw4_BexMyhR2KLJ0cYaQ_uo1wu_MIf4aKQUri0QlfGEXnnoVOOZoqGK_hh5VMQK4l2NDW0Z9mFF8WVWUcbLQ-eiyV-Q2T0En-DK8R3NGdIQ-Of4mkmfNHRo9kTfNl1fEl4fEZzRoa-G30e5Kxxdh167Wg4fajLo7QevMMZnWiqikd15LnQKDz07HCYZLizwz9uiNGPmiWu9Ma-Cn2EpsZ9fNzxD02qox-aHtWPx00y7HGOh-gFLYrcCJ8SGteLf0P8vGiqJUOXJMOZByclZBfRJMuhURvy3PiDRj9OSZmMJ2lbeM-GCyFUScwRR1JElGqmCUweDeePG2HOQTu7IL8kvMrRvWh2fMfHJ8j3wVd2XMqgK9dQ6ugPHl2U8GhKBbRxhip-47qkwI0nnIfcPEHIXEQTCU9GEbUDP3nQ4yopxFMYyOODJp98hI0rnMX0EOlz4TL0vNimRUf7DPmdEE8e4TgR5uLQOzgVFmcKXUGT6ynKHm00eEuCe5qgJXyHs8cpa0M60niWPTh_hBGLUyHEHzzDEDUf8FkSGT9RRWGLJtJWQXeOE2G643qI_lnxZMHEMAqm7MEf5IROGk0uhKvEgw8-4wyH78ajE2FG_eijHLqk4FmOMFlO_Bd8HicPRrsoIVxOOFSGvjx0DT9KW0KbahMeEVeO6iq0fB4-F3GNL_hh49LQewhDPirO8NB1XAnCZD_63Mjz4Xpxw39wQkvKw3L0o1_BdkfcHE3oGG2USyjXNQi949nBZ9COH-VCC1d2xI9GoUeYSjR0-cFI5UP4Ho0Uvcb-4MePpsuF8DP-QR_eMDrC7EMtHk9T5KfwoIk0o05O6MInPA9yJYf74j6DLj2ajLOEkEoIV82hZ0S_I_iFa0tG4YqkYP8YojlCSqWwBzpzhL_QpOIkfEGbXWgepUG-H_qIH36OP3it4eIhJ3yRzubw4sOpLLhIC98TNIpsVG2OfFAT-Wgof7jkwz_yI9eloe9x8kPeKUaT56i3IM-h6D985ElCTM1241OG7_Ad_EdcRXgkaHlmFD_xhBHukcjDRxEahkWpZHiEp8RzfHaQRkqY48p-XP8gSkdEsSMuoj9cot-Pq5GDK1tyxMUVfEL65Lib4zt6xQyaVmiSGNX2ILcFPVmC_OilD1OOP_iShMQjHb-J5jlCM_rwFc-O34fuaAka50PIZCOBWH6ELqosbJkORRZzQUfhUkeohnnwOkgr4ddovImJUFNywqOOnvjxJDr6ZUezD7FzXNqhaU_RdDNyPTiNazkm9oG5o9cRcokOsRRy9mjCHZeu4FLowMcdEqX0wpRLRNbhM8IPlzm0RMuFZ1EuyGLhHNeHXagPf0adB9eyozWa-bhoPLkCPcIFRydmJcJVJvjRI636YN50PNGOO0dIKyEe8YHGJVeGMHWKZxMuPUKjREdlfrjDoA9cveiPZ5qGT8ctatHQaD6qhjG-Yz_6oqn04HFxpM-FW4KeHD8RhpGUGJN3vA_eHn-4FC_a8kjHDXeiH-Le4ePxwEf1aRh9lE8oSFoUHn2GU-GCXEd5OMuPPB9-w7wFjT1CGUz0C5d-_GB5ofmjoqKYCzkTkeh0KGSPFy5ylsPR7DieMIiP89D2OGjGJ8iTBHuLXkfzHt1247ngI_wLHSc68vB5hD-6C3kOH6XEHLp5PNGHH6GF5sd0Fa6PC6kmBic-D_oe1BeeJMPRHVPG7HiO-oHYZGB75MeHyzhj_Ed6lD--4UetiERTH187vMcb9EbjBscVHbWPxmmJD9rh5wi7HY9RK5EFH2GPi9AV5TiP8MejC3-IlMlRb3gWNB-04wkjXNnB7Pmg5biPK8LRtIkPxj6-on3RhBp-4w36ozneDT2s9QCAACLMAAqAsUSAYAxzABBBCXJAAMGAQwYZJQwD3BCCjGJAAOECQAABwogQAiDBAHLMACEQQ0IAIyADlACgDBNCASSQAgwgZ4RSwANlBGEICSqCQUIAAwRDACEiBHJOEGKRQ4QpIpAjUCRIBADQAAKEIkAhKCkxAADEkDJIACUIEAIIRIgSBBlDpACFAIEAwUAhgZxChBhjHEEAGU8kgAIQx4wRGikurAEACCAIIsAhBJCkyAiBGRAIASMkQE4IAARCTkCDBJHCGCCIwYYYQRwwSCqDiICYIAEAJUIQZIQgClAoCDCACMAMYIYBYRAiSgEiGABIEAEMchAYY4BgShAiDDbCAYUMU4AogoCzSDABEDKIMUIIE846g4QQngAAAGBEAWQUEAAhRxwAgAABiBAEECAMEgwQYRRgQCIjBATAAIEVcEJAZIwURhhhAAFOAEQUc0ggYIkARDCgkCBKCCUAMcA4AoAiggjBhPHGCEIAg4gpADRBABAABDhCACEQQQwoIIgQCAEhABHAASAAIYIIwyhAyADEmJGEGOwYEUYBIwwRxhABhCAKCEEMwgpJxIQDBSECAGEQCEEMIYAMhJQATBjAqCEiIaEAEsoIIIhCQEgBENWCIIAAJZExZ4QCACiFHEAKCEAEAVYgBIQwhDCpCFIACYUUAAY5IwQQwCghCBCAAAAMIoQILhQCCCkgFCJIAOWogAYgAYAgDAEjAAACaYIEIggBI4gRAlHigLBAIAGIgUQQwgABTghCBBJCgqAAIQwIAgRjCiAoBBAECEQYcA4wAJABiFhiBSMAICSUE8gRDSBBABpAGGAOICGAJcgAiKRRnCAJiBSIEkIIEIIQAQQgAAlrmGACMaIVQQIZQYADwBhigBFCS0VEQAgwRhARhgFiEEJCcCQABAgQiAACDBAkLBKGOSSAcQpQ4JxChgBggHhEKCSMEsJRBIDwwDoECALCKYUYIFIxoBACBJjAiAuICESEgJRZCA&duration=251&client=v8pQ6oyB&clientversion=2.8.3.final0&format=json'
D: 22:12:33,145 webservice\ratecontrol.get_delay_to_next_request:118: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): Last request was 114210 ms ago, starting another one
D: 22:12:33,145 webservice\ratecontrol.increment_requests:138: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): Incrementing requests to: 1
D: 22:12:33,452 webservice\ratecontrol.decrement_requests:146: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): Decrementing requests to: 0
D: 22:12:33,452 webservice\__init__._handle_reply:540: Received reply for https://api.acoustid.org/v2/lookup: HTTP 200 (OK) 
D: 22:12:33,453 webservice\__init__._handle_reply:553: Response received: {'results': [{'id': '674f06c2-4135-499b-9daa-03724acb5ac7', 'recordings': [{'id': '837a0c07-9da1-40fa-953c-8f1f58c4187f', 'sources': 52}], 'score': 1.0}], 'status': 'ok'}
D: 22:12:33,453 acoustid\__init__._on_lookup_finished:132: AcoustID: Lookup successful for 'E:\!!RippityRip\+CDs\Pixies\[2022] Doggerel\1-01 - Pixies - Nomatterday.flac' (recordings: 1)
D: 22:12:33,453 ui\mainwindow.set_statusbar_message:459: File 'E:\!!RippityRip\+CDs\Pixies\[2022] Doggerel\1-01 - Pixies - Nomatterday.flac' identified!
D: 22:12:33,453 file.move:628: Moving <FLACFile '1-01 - Pixies - Nomatterday.flac'> from <Cluster 'Unclustered Files'> to <Cluster NATS '[standalone recordings]/Unmatched Files'>
D: 22:12:33,455 webservice\ratecontrol._out_of_backoff:222: ('api.acoustid.org', 443): oobackoff; delay: 500ms -> 333ms; slow start; window size 2.000 -> 3.000
D: 22:12:33,455 webservice\ratecontrol.get_delay_to_next_request:118: ('musicbrainz.org', 443): Last request was 114168 ms ago, starting another one
D: 22:12:33,455 webservice\ratecontrol.increment_requests:138: ('musicbrainz.org', 443): Incrementing requests to: 1
D: 22:12:33,719 webservice\ratecontrol.decrement_requests:146: ('musicbrainz.org', 443): Decrementing requests to: 0
D: 22:12:33,720 webservice\__init__._handle_reply:540: Received reply for https://musicbrainz.org/ws/2/recording/837a0c07-9da1-40fa-953c-8f1f58c4187f?inc=work-level-rels+recording-rels+genres+artists+artist-rels+aliases+url-rels+artist-credits+work-rels: HTTP 200 (OK) 
D: 22:12:33,720 webservice\__init__._handle_reply:553: Response received: {'aliases': [], 'artist-credit': [{'name': 'Pixies', 'artist': {'type-id': 'e431f5f6-b5d2-343d-8b36-72607fffb74b', 'genres': [{'count': 1, 'id': '00055e8b-b951-46e2-af1e-58b5624e7952', 'name': 'acoustic rock', 'disambiguation': ''}, {'id': 'ceeaa283-5d7b-4202-8d1d-e25d116b2a18', 'name': 'alternative rock', 'disambiguation': '', 'count': 11}, {'id': 'ccd19ebf-052c-4afe-8ad9-fbb0a73f94a7', 'disambiguation': '', 'name': 'indie rock', 'count': 4}, {'count': 1, 'name': 'punk rock', 'disambiguation': '', 'id': 'bd7e1d40-43b1-4ba5-97b3-05b891466962'}, {'count': 4, 'disambiguation': '', 'name': 'rock', 'id': '0e3fc579-2d24-4f20-9dae-736e1ec78798'}], 'id': 'b6b2bb8d-54a9-491f-9607-7b546023b433', 'sort-name': 'Pixies', 'aliases': [{'primary': None, 'sort-name': 'Poxies', 'ended': False, 'begin': None, 'type': None, 'name': 'Poxies', 'end': None, 'type-id': None, 'locale': None}, {'end': None, 'type': None, 'name': 'The Pixies', 'begin': None, 'ended': False, 'sort-name': 'The Pixies', 'primary': None, 'locale': None, 'type-id': None}], 'type': 'Group', 'disambiguation': '', 'name': 'Pixies'}, 'joinphrase': ''}], 'length': 251453, 'disambiguation': '', 'title': 'Nomatterday', 'video': False, 'relations': [{'attribute-ids': {}, 'type': 'engineer', 'target-credit': '', 'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'attributes': [], 'ended': False, 'begin': None, 'artist': {'id': '3597bd2f-8eb2-4afd-9145-d841b51f1086', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Tom Dalgety', 'disambiguation': '', 'sort-name': 'Dalgety, Tom', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df'}, 'target-type': 'artist', 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': '', 'type-id': '5dcc52af-7064-4051-8d62-7d80f4c3c907'}, {'target-type': 'artist', 'source-credit': '', 'attribute-values': {}, 'type-id': '5dcc52af-7064-4051-8d62-7d80f4c3c907', 'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'ended': False, 'attributes': ['assistant'], 'artist': {'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'sort-name': 'Hall, Matt', 'disambiguation': 'sound engineer', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Matt Hall', 'id': '8b7c5e7d-4ef9-4d46-9e91-aa2c2c3c3dab'}, 'begin': None, 'target-credit': '', 'attribute-ids': {'assistant': '8c4196b1-7053-4b16-921a-f22b2898ed44'}, 'type': 'engineer'}, {'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'begin': None, 'artist': {'id': 'd9d4d3d4-32e6-4822-b858-b8195ba4d073', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Dave Snyder', 'disambiguation': 'drummer & engineer, Guilford Sound', 'sort-name': 'Snyder, Dave', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df'}, 'ended': False, 'attributes': ['assistant'], 'target-type': 'artist', 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': '', 'type-id': '5dcc52af-7064-4051-8d62-7d80f4c3c907', 'attribute-ids': {'assistant': '8c4196b1-7053-4b16-921a-f22b2898ed44'}, 'type': 'engineer', 'target-credit': ''}, {'type': 'instrument', 'attribute-ids': {'guitar': '63021302-86cd-4aee-80df-2270d54f4978'}, 'target-credit': '', 'artist': {'sort-name': 'Black Francis', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'id': '789f6768-5830-4b08-8b4f-f38566b2eb1d', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Black Francis', 'disambiguation': 'US singer, songwriter & guitarist'}, 'begin': None, 'attribute-credits': {}, 'ended': False, 'attributes': ['guitar'], 'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': '', 'type-id': '59054b12-01ac-43ee-a618-285fd397e461', 'target-type': 'artist'}, {'attribute-ids': {'keyboard': '95b0c3d2-9606-4ef5-a019-9b7437f3adda'}, 'type': 'instrument', 'target-credit': '', 'end': None, 'direction': 'backward', 'attribute-credits': {}, 'begin': None, 'artist': {'name': 'Paz Lenchantin', 'type': 'Person', 'disambiguation': '', 'id': '45b1e8a0-0757-4b0f-99e2-bbba94af1557', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'sort-name': 'Lenchantin, Paz'}, 'ended': False, 'attributes': ['keyboard'], 'target-type': 'artist', 'type-id': '59054b12-01ac-43ee-a618-285fd397e461', 'source-credit': '', 'attribute-values': {}}, {'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'attribute-credits': {}, 'begin': None, 'artist': {'sort-name': 'Lenchantin, Paz', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'id': '45b1e8a0-0757-4b0f-99e2-bbba94af1557', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Paz Lenchantin', 'disambiguation': ''}, 'ended': False, 'attributes': ['bass guitar'], 'target-type': 'artist', 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': '', 'type-id': '59054b12-01ac-43ee-a618-285fd397e461', 'type': 'instrument', 'attribute-ids': {'bass guitar': '17f9f065-2312-4a24-8309-6f6dd63e2e33'}, 'target-credit': ''}, {'artist': {'sort-name': 'Lovering, Dave', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'id': '211dc1cc-2d75-4413-8e65-ef0501e1a356', 'name': 'Dave Lovering', 'type': 'Person', 'disambiguation': ''}, 'attribute-credits': {}, 'begin': None, 'attributes': ['drums (drum set)'], 'ended': False, 'end': None, 'direction': 'backward', 'type-id': '59054b12-01ac-43ee-a618-285fd397e461', 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': '', 'target-type': 'artist', 'type': 'instrument', 'attribute-ids': {'drums (drum set)': '12092505-6ee1-46af-a15a-b5b468b6b155'}, 'target-credit': ''}, {'attribute-credits': {}, 'artist': {'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Joey Santiago', 'disambiguation': '', 'id': 'a51cfe50-b22b-4d01-8720-b3cacfeb3c58', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'sort-name': 'Santiago, Joey'}, 'begin': None, 'ended': False, 'attributes': ['guitar'], 'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'source-credit': '', 'attribute-values': {}, 'type-id': '59054b12-01ac-43ee-a618-285fd397e461', 'target-type': 'artist', 'attribute-ids': {'guitar': '63021302-86cd-4aee-80df-2270d54f4978'}, 'type': 'instrument', 'target-credit': ''}, {'target-type': 'artist', 'source-credit': '', 'attribute-values': {}, 'type-id': '3e3102e1-1896-4f50-b5b2-dd9824e46efe', 'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'attributes': [], 'ended': False, 'artist': {'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'sort-name': 'Dalgety, Tom', 'name': 'Tom Dalgety', 'type': 'Person', 'disambiguation': '', 'id': '3597bd2f-8eb2-4afd-9145-d841b51f1086'}, 'begin': None, 'target-credit': '', 'attribute-ids': {}, 'type': 'mix'}, {'attribute-ids': {}, 'type': 'producer', 'target-credit': '', 'end': None, 'direction': 'backward', 'begin': None, 'artist': {'sort-name': 'Dalgety, Tom', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'id': '3597bd2f-8eb2-4afd-9145-d841b51f1086', 'name': 'Tom Dalgety', 'type': 'Person', 'disambiguation': ''}, 'ended': False, 'attributes': [], 'target-type': 'artist', 'type-id': '5c0ceac3-feb4-41f0-868d-dc06f6e27fc0', 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': ''}, {'type': 'vocal', 'attribute-ids': {}, 'target-credit': '', 'direction': 'backward', 'end': None, 'ended': False, 'attributes': [], 'begin': None, 'artist': {'disambiguation': 'US singer, songwriter & guitarist', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Black Francis', 'id': '789f6768-5830-4b08-8b4f-f38566b2eb1d', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'sort-name': 'Black Francis'}, 'target-type': 'artist', 'source-credit': '', 'attribute-values': {}, 'type-id': '0fdbe3c6-7700-4a31-ae54-b53f06ae1cfa'}, {'attribute-ids': {'background vocals': '75052401-7340-4e5b-a71d-ea024a128849'}, 'type': 'vocal', 'target-credit': '', 'artist': {'id': '45b1e8a0-0757-4b0f-99e2-bbba94af1557', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Paz Lenchantin', 'disambiguation': '', 'sort-name': 'Lenchantin, Paz', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df'}, 'begin': None, 'attribute-credits': {}, 'attributes': ['background vocals'], 'ended': False, 'end': None, 'direction': 'backward', 'type-id': '0fdbe3c6-7700-4a31-ae54-b53f06ae1cfa', 'source-credit': '', 'attribute-values': {}, 'target-type': 'artist'}, {'target-credit': '', 'work': {'iswcs': [], 'languages': ['eng'], 'id': '7dba3e96-31e9-4e93-a96e-6840d1e5dad3', 'type-id': 'f061270a-2fd6-32f1-a641-f0f8676d14e6', 'relations': [{'artist': {'disambiguation': 'US singer, songwriter & guitarist', 'type': 'Person', 'name': 'Black Francis', 'id': '789f6768-5830-4b08-8b4f-f38566b2eb1d', 'type-id': 'b6e035f4-3ce9-331c-97df-83397230b0df', 'sort-name': 'Black Francis'}, 'begin': None, 'ended': False, 'attributes': [], 'end': None, 'direction': 'backward', 'type-id': 'a255bca1-b157-4518-9108-7b147dc3fc68', 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': '', 'target-type': 'artist', 'attribute-ids': {}, 'type': 'writer', 'target-credit': ''}], 'title': 'Nomatterday', 'language': 'eng', 'type': 'Song', 'disambiguation': '', 'attributes': []}, 'type': 'performance', 'attribute-ids': {}, 'attribute-values': {}, 'source-credit': '', 'type-id': 'a3005666-a872-32c3-ad06-98af558e99b0', 'target-type': 'work', 'begin': None, 'ended': False, 'attributes': [], 'direction': 'forward', 'end': None}], 'genres': [], 'first-release-date': '2022-09-29', 'id': '837a0c07-9da1-40fa-953c-8f1f58c4187f'}
D: 22:12:33,721 file.move:628: Moving <FLACFile '1-01 - Pixies - Nomatterday.flac'> from <Cluster NATS '[standalone recordings]/Unmatched Files'> to <Track 837a0c07-9da1-40fa-953c-8f1f58c4187f 'Nomatterday'>
D: 22:12:33,724 webservice\ratecontrol._out_of_backoff:222: ('musicbrainz.org', 443): oobackoff; delay: 1000ms -> 1000ms; slow start; window size 4.000 -> 5.000

image

2 Likes

Anybody can reproduce this by submitting fingerprints for new music.

1 Like

Thanks. Give me some time to look into this. Things currently take a bit longer on my side.

EDIT: Tracked on [PICARD-2584] Handle AcoustID missing metadata - MetaBrainz JIRA

3 Likes

Has anybody contacted @lukz - because if it is not showing MusicBrainz metadata on Acoustid after a few days then that indicates an issue with Acoustid.

Doggerel is over a month since submission…

I think I reported essentially the same thing not too long ago: Picard can't match AcoustID of a track, but the AcoustID is added. In that thread @Zas asked @lukz to look into possible replication issues, but there was no reply. Maybe he’s not reading this forum?

Was just coming to look for information about this same thing, good that it’s a known issue. :+1: