When was the vinyl or cassette released? If it was released at the same time/same lable as a CD, you could match the style of the CD. So in your example, I would think a circa 1987 vinyl/cassette would match the 1987 CD style (#1). If it was in 1997, then it would be style #3.
That's just my thought, I'm certainly not the expert, but it makes sense to me!