How does peer review work?

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007fe31140e5b0>

Hello everyone! I’m wondering how peer review works. A couple of things I’ve edited have been “added to the queue,” but I’m not sure exactly what that means. Do people automatically get alerted, or do I need to post these things somewhere for them to be looked at?

1 Like

When you enter certain (destructive, non-recoverable) edits, or if you are a new editor, the edits are entered into a queue for review and voting. See https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Introduction_to_Voting for more information.

7 Likes

Welcome!!

Peeping at your edits list might make it a bit clearer as well.
To do so, go to your profile page (in MB, not in this forum) and click ‘edits’, bringing you to: https://musicbrainz.org/user/PunkWillNeverDie44/edits
Click ‘open edits’ for just the ones that are in the queue.

1 Like

Basically, you have to wait for 7 days.
If no one votes your edit get accepted.

If someone votes against your edit (“No vote”) you need at least 2 “Yes votes” to get your edit accepted nevertheless. Most of the time such a “No vote” has an explanation why it is not a good idea to accept your edit. Some ot the “No voters” can be convinced that your edit is fine (but honestly, this will happen very rarely :wink:).

2 Likes