Expanding Available Credits

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007f41a30fe060>

Hello! I’m posting this topic in an attempt to bring attention the MusicBrainz’s metadata limitations and hopefully create a space to unify people’s ideas about what should be added.

Most importantly, I think that all roles should provide users with the ability to further specify the task within that role. This feature, which is already present within the producer role, would benefit the site by cutting down on the need for sub-optimal credits, which I find myself having to use quite often, especially when it comes to photography. It would also better account for any major changes in technology use in the future, such as the increasing popularity Pro-Tools engineering during the pandemic.

Here’s a photo of the producer field in case you don’t know what I’m talking about. Note the ability to specify a task within the producer role. This is what I think should be expanded to all roles.

Next on the list is video roles. Because music videos are so popular in the music industry, I think an expansion of video roles is in order. Some important roles include the screenwriter, filmer, cinematographer, director of photography, production designer, costume designer, and production company.

Finally, I think the are some more minor tweaks that would be helpful. Just small role additions, such as:

  • management (artist)
  • disc enhancement (artist)
  • layout (artist)
  • art concept (artist)
  • design concept (artist)
  • non-instrument technician (artist)
  • record company (label)

Any additional comments or contributions welcome

3 Likes

Are you aware of the tickets?

J2DASH - MetaBrainz JIRA

You can request tweaks and additional roles, etc. there. Search for these there as many of these may already be in the pipeline or denied with a reason why.

3 Likes

Yes, I’m aware, thanks. The post here was more meant to bring wider attention to the problem as well as allowing people suggest roles that I may not have thought of. Furthermore, this would likely be a larger project that may not fit the scope of ticket suggestions.

2 Likes

I’m also interested in music videos but sometimes I can’t add many of the credits and have to stuff them into the annotation. E.g.

BTW, RateYourMusic recently introduced music videos:

7 Likes