Conflicting artists on same release

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007fe319bdd7c0>

I’m trying to enter this release, which was originally acquired from Amazon but isn’t there anymore.

Deezer also has it, and the artists basically match.

And then there’s Spotify, where many of the artists are totally different.

It looks like some of this may be due to Alfred Scholz pseudonyms which Spotify has unpacked, but it’s hard to be sure about all of them. How would you deal with this? Enter two releases with different ACs?

3 Likes

I typically throw away Spotify-specific track titles and artist credits. In my experience, Spotify does some radical “standardizing” of their track titles (like replacing sets of parentheses with a leading hyphen) as well as “standardization” of artist credits by not having the concept of join phrases.

edit: But if Classical applies to this release, then the artist credits may not actually matter…

1 Like

You’re right, the credits should follow CSG. But the performers can still be credited. My main concern is figuring out what the heck the credits mean. Look at the first track: Google and Deezer list Budapest Philharmonic Orchestra. Deezer also has János Sándor. Those appear to be legit credits in MusicBrainz, but Spotify has “London Festival Orchestra Alfred Scholz”. :man_shrugging:t3:

1 Like

Spotify id 5sDZlZ5TX4hmeV767XqewP isn’t available anymore, for this reason I’m guessing they replace some songs by equivalent.
You can use Fetching ISRCs from Spotify tool and/or a-tisket and obtain the original tracklist.

It does look like the typical Alfred Scholz fare. The Budapest Philharmonic Orchestra is on the list of possibly fraudulently used artist names. And “Feel Good Classics” is just the kind of cheap, crappy compilation that you would expect those recordings to turn up on.

I think it would be good to have a catch-all “Alfred Scholz’ Bogus Orchestra” artist to consolidate all those recordings on, and use artist credits on the releases. Without the physical release, it’s going to be pretty hard to establish which name is used here, but does it really matter?

1 Like

Tangential:
If someone has access to these and other (possibly) Scholz recordings - what does Shazam return on them?

Shazam might give us enough confidence to move these sort of recordings from “possibly Scholz” to " Sholz"

For sure. I doubt there was a physical release of this one. There’s currently a #2 on Amazon, but this one has vanished into the ether.