CAA refuses new uploads for a specific release

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007f4d56b19888>

Today I encountered a strange error in connection with the CAA that I’ve never seen before.
But before I’ll give a description of the impacts, I’m going to start with the chronological background story of the problem:

Another editor tried to upload (additional) images to a release and I wanted to vote on them, but they could not be viewed in any size. After I had told them that their edits look empty, they tried to upload them again – with the same result. I couldn’t believe this and started my own attempt to upload one of these pictures – and failed too :face_with_monocle:

This is what happens: After “successfully” uploading the image with the AJAX uploader, the resulting edit shows the usual We are unable to display history for this cover art. For a current listing of cover art, please see the release’s cover art page.
So far nothing special… but when I visit the cover art art page, usually it’s only the thumbnail links that are not working shortly after the upload. This time I also get a Page not found error for the original link!
Looking directly at the files on the IA server, there’s only an older upload, but no trace of the new images or any of the failed attempts.

The issue seems specific to the release, because other recent CA uploads can be displayed just fine. Has anyone ever experienced similar issues with the CAA and/or is able to explain this? The only similar ticket I found is CAA-119.

https://archive.org/history/mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a

Waiting to run 19
Running 0
Waiting for admin 0
Parked 0
Other 0
Finished 17
server readonly -- tasks waiting for harddrive fix
disk readonly -- tasks waiting for rescue task
Tasks
identifier task_id server cmd submittime submitter args
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1641352145 archive.php (1.5 hour) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www51..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1641352031 archive.php (1.5 hour) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www38..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1641351637 archive.php (1.5 hour) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www41..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640732602 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www35..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640732484 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www38..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640732073 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www39..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640731848 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www48..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640731761 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www46..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640731432 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www53..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640729669 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www48..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640729597 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www39..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640728919 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www37..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1640728764 archive.php (8.3 hours) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www42..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1638092798 archive.php (1.5 day) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www50..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1638092723 archive.php (1.5 day) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www43..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1638092428 archive.php (1.5 day) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www36..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1638092091 archive.php (1.5 day) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www53..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1638092047 archive.php (1.5 day) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www49..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 1638091769 ia600303.us.archive.org archive.php (1.5 day) caa@musicbrainz.org from_url=rsync://h6.www51..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 877094488 ia600303.us.archive.org modify_xml.php (2.0 years) alexis@archive.org key=9400770-30018&noindex..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 850211905 ia600303.us.archive.org bup.php (2.1 years) caa@musicbrainz.org dir=/6/items/mbid-eec3655..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 850211183 iw600206 derive.php (2.1 years) caa@musicbrainz.org remove_derived=*.jpg&serv..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 523044058 ia600303.us.archive.org modify_xml.php (3.9 years) hank@archive.org backup_location[99]=ia903..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 523043506 ia903805.us.archive.org archive.php (3.9 years) hank@archive.org shuffle=1&from_url=rsync:..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 408978919 ia600303.us.archive.org archive.php (4.9 years) hank@archive.org shuffle=1&from_url=rsync:..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 308306360 ia601205.us.archive.org modify_xml.php (5.9 years) kaplan@archive.org key=12267683-445&mediatyp..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 287102091 ia601205.us.archive.org bup.php (6.2 years) jake@archive.org key=3784727-22092&dir=/15..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 287102030 iw600700 derive.php (6.2 years) jake@archive.org key=3784727-22092&comment..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 148073852 ia601205.us.archive.org bup.php (7.1 years) hank@archive.org key=5110803&dir=/15/items..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 148073807 iw600206.us.archive.org derive.php (7.1 years) hank@archive.org key=5110803&comment=reder..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 111284307 ia601205.us.archive.org bup.php (7.8 years) caa@musicbrainz.org dir=/15/items/mbid-eec365..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 111282950 iw600302.us.archive.org derive.php (7.8 years) caa@musicbrainz.org server_primary=ia601205.u..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 111282872 ia601205.us.archive.org archive.php (7.8 years) caa@musicbrainz.org done=delsrc&from_url=rsyn..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 109562375 ia601205.us.archive.org bup.php (7.8 years) caa@musicbrainz.org dir=/15/items/mbid-eec365..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 109562363 iw600704.us.archive.org derive.php (7.8 years) caa@musicbrainz.org server_primary=ia601205.u..
mbid-eec3655c-3171-44b7-b6b4-9682da4d038a - History Mgr 109562311 ia601205.us.archive.org archive.php (7.8 years) caa@musicbrainz.org done=delsrc&from_url=rsyn..
1 Like

Thumbnail generation takes a while but original files not showing up might be a bad sign.
I suppose more people than usual are uploading stuff, that or something broke.

1 Like

I see this sometimes that the “original file” links don’t work immediately after uploading.

It usually clears in a few minutes.

Personally I’d check back tomorrow to see if it’s still busted.

1 Like

Yeah, this is a weird one since the other releases in the RG have cover art. I’ve seen similar things happen when there’s a copyright issue but then usually all of the cover art will be deleted.

I also remember a similar event from a few months ago where it said that the files had been removed from the servers (the files were uploaded several years ago), but then a day later or something like that they magically reappeared and I had to cancel my CAA removal edits.

1 Like

The problem has solved itself, the CAA has finally accepted the pictures after 2 days. Even the aborted attempts are there :hourglass: :partying_face: