Beat Culture - Forgive (never released)

musicbrainz
Tags: #<Tag:0x00007fe3d0a83278>

#1

Hi

the following entry was never released, please can you remove it ?

According to Union Art:

“This work was not released on both CD and LP by various reason.”

This is the answer i got from the label. So entry should not exist.

Thanks in advance.


#2

You can enter the “remove” edit yourself if you like.
Normally we discourage removing data as per our Data Removal Policy, but unreleased music is such a dangerous grey area that I believe we should err on the side of caution and not allow it. Many others have disagreed with this; we discussed it a while back in previous threads:



#3

I think it is interesting information for a music database, whether it was released or not.
I would however disambiguate and annotate it, the way it’s curently presented (as a legitimate release) is definitely wrong. I wish we had a new ‘cancelled’ type or something that hides it from the official release discography which is not correct, but I guess MB’s not perfect yet.


#4

There is a ticket in the pipeline for it.


#5

In the meantime, is it correct if i edit to add something like “unofficial and unreleased” ?

Edit: done