Should different remix singles be merged into one release group?

[chaban]

@reosarevok

This case of a single should be obvious enough based on your example:

Requests for Votes Thread

I don’t think this “argument” is gonna go anywhere: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/112720236 Simple enough release group merge of the same single.

@reosarevok

The thing is for singles, remixes are basically expected and often packaged with the original mix. So, you’d often have a situation like:

Single (1 track) in RG 1
Single (3 tracks, inc. 2 remixes) in RG 1
Single (the 2 remixes on their own)

It seems very strange not to put that in RG 1 too.

Thanks to the new remix guidelines people are now arguing that remix singles should be their own release group.