this came from an edit post
please evaluate these 2 pages
https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/d84ada68-4db2-35ce-906e-4ed7da0554ab/open_edits
https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/619e8f96-575f-43e8-afeb-154594b58dd5/open_edits
I want release group, release, recordings to all appear on group and each artists pages without duplication
It took several attempts
Please look these over and confirm that I got it right
I will have to do this on many pages where I exchanged artists for group so releases wouild appear on artists page
Now I realized I can have it both ways, my cake and eat it too
Please fellow editors, look these over for errors and miscalculations
I have a lot of work to do on my previous edits
and this is how I will do things going forward
this way we get artists with full listings with losing group or Luike the Drifter
I got this idea while I was writing a comment for this ticket https://tickets.metabrainz.org/browse/MBS-4683
make sure you vote for this if haven’t already
These tools will help us better present labels, imprints, artists, groups without unnecessary duplication, but also an artists indivdual, group and pseudonym works together and indivdually.
A few months ago, Hank Williams work was spread over about five different pages, I noticed when I couldn’t find stuff. At this point, I was just like a visitor to the site, and I was having trouble looking things up.
So as an editor, and with the agreement of other editors, I made it so they would all show up on Hank Williams page. But now Luke the Drifter’s page was empty. I would like it to show up there too, for those who go looking for Luke only. Well, no problem, I just have to go back and re-edit some items.
Gene Autry trio used to go to a Gene Autry Trio page, which only had one or two items, generated from various artists compilations. At first, I thought it was better if they showed up on Gene Autry’s page. Now I think it would be best if they show up on the GAT page, as well Gene Autry, Jimmy Long, and Smiley Burnette’s pages, so our readers can find stuff, and also see the full career accomplishments of each of the members.
Sounds good, but I must have overlooked something, so tell me what it is.