Hi IvanDobsky,jesus2099,and all.
thanks for Suggestion.
I was encouraged by everyone’s consent.
I would like to describe the description on the menu screen that should indicate the artist’s intention.
Also, I did not notice when posting this question, but I fully agree with the opinion that as you said carefully.
Hidden information that can not easily be seen on the menu (Easter eggs and like these), we should be added as much as possible.
I will try to describe these hidden informations as necessary.
Below, as an example, I will show the problem that I currently face.
Region code is not set for this DVD - R, there is no layer break.
CSS, and other copy controls are also not added DVD-R.
Therefore, my conduct is legitimate.
This DVD - R has the following directory structure.
UNTITTLED_PROJECT
│
├Menus
│└─Title Menu
│ └─English
│ ├Menue 1 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ ├Menue 2 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ ├Menue 3 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ ├(snip)
│ ├Menue 9 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ └Menue 10 00:00:00 0.01MB
├VTS 1
│ └─English
│ ├Root Menue 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ ├Menue 2 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ └Menue 3 00:00:20 0.58MB #A
├VTS 2
│ └─English
│ ├Root Menue 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ └Menue 2 00:00:00 0.01MB
├VTS 3
│ └─English
│ ├Root Menue 00:00:00 0.01MB
│ └Menue 2 00:00:00 0.01MB
├Main Movie
│ └─Title 3 01:04:29 3,521MB #B
└Extras
├─Title 1 00:03:47 206MB #C
├─Title 2 00:09:27 516MB #D
└─Title 4 00:03:13 174MB #E
#B-#E is displayed in the menu.
The menu is #A (VTS_01_0.VOB), which is 20 seconds.
We input this hidden file #A at the top of the chapter list.
and then #B-#E in the order shown on the #A screen.
(not Sort by Title 1,2,3,4.)
May we do this procedure?
So, Related doubts.
Does the DVDs “Disc IDs” not exist?
Picard 2.1.2 for Windows could not be detected.
Are there any types of DVDs that can be detected?
Or is it all impossible for DVDs?
Please let me know if anyone knows.
I’m not a computer engineer, so I might be saying misguided.
Unlike CD, DVD has no TOC.
In my delusion, if Picard uses a hash of “VIDEO_TS.IFO”, if possible to uniquely identify a variety of DVDs?
And More!
I agree with Ivandobsky’s opinion very much.
I also wanted to write it separately by each song.
As a matter of fact, the DVD-R I have at hand now is the official release of the artist.
But its long long live performance is linear like the fan cam which was taken at the outdoor music festival.
No electronic chapters have been struck between songs and songs.
I think it is unkind to cram multiple songs into one box, separated by a tilde or slash.
However, there seems to be a different opinion.
Below is an opinion that contradicts my intentions.
https://musicbrainz.org/edit/59397169
For example, let’s say we have a relatively long MC talk ( master of ceremony ) between a song and a song.
The start point of the MC talk should be different a few seconds by the person who uses the stopwatch.
Therefore, what he is saying is logically correct though it contradicts my intention.
That I admit too.
But what if the MB system has a “NEW box” to enter the total time?
In other words, write one song or MC in one box.
And, we describe to “NEW box” only the total time of that DVD.
If it is possible, I think that would be convenient for everyone in a simpler.
Is it may difficult to renovate the system?
Anyway, perhaps, the demand of the system renovation is not to discuss it in this place.
But I’m still a beginner - Trust Level 1 - and don’t have the experience to commit deeply to the community.
It would be nice if someone in the veterans - Regulars, Leaders - could work together to tell the developers and deepen the discussion.
My mother tongue is not English, so I’m worried whether the choice of words is right.
For example the difference between ‘still’ and ‘yet’ nuances.
There may be many other rude writing styles, but there is no malice. Sorry.
Thank you, everyone, for reading with long time.