Help test the relationship editor on beta.musicbrainz.org

[reosarevok]

@joiletjake

The correct number of relationships are displayed on the left side, but it’s only displayed once on the right side regardless of how many “recording of” rels there are, but that’s perhaps intended?

That’s intended - the left shows the relationships, the right shows the works (once). It might not be the most intuitive though, given some comments on this thread.

@joiletjake

There’s still an inconsistency for “credited as”, where it’s displayed in a separate for instruments, but in the clickable blue AC for artists and you have to hover over to see the original AC. The latter should be used for both imo.

I think that’s intentional either because that’s not always a 1:1 replacement for the instrument/vocals (for example, you’ll sometimes see opera singers listed as “soprano vocals [Role]: Artist”, where replacing “soprano vocals” with “Role” would probably not be an improvement - same for “violin [1st]: Artist”)

@joiletjake

The grouping (or headlines) of the relationships in these droplist could be clearer though. Light-grey headlines are hard to spot when the rest is black

Them being grey is meant to show they can’t be selected, but maybe it can be made a bit more visible while still being clear. I added a ticket for that (MBS-12866)