I’ve come across an (or rather multiple) issue(s). That or I’m overthinking things.
Case 1 and 2 actually involve the same recording (video)
Among other things it samples Trump dancing in the Saturday Night Live parody of Hotline Bling
How would one go about adding this information? I see multiple options:
- Add Trump as visual appearance
- Relate it to the (yet to be added) Hotline Bling parody
There is no relationship specifically for video samples. Would be using the sample relationship fine or is it for audio samples only?
This question doesn’t come out of nowhere. I’ve recently added a video recording whose audio portion is sampled in another recording of the same release (and several other recordings). And now I can’t help but wonder if the sample relationship is correctly used that way.
An audio-only version doesn’t exist as far as I know.
You could say as opposed to that kid I do need help
I guess I could do both but doesn’t that go against the spirit of the relationships style guide?
BTW
Trump’s inauguration speech was also being sampled (hence the title “America First”) but that one was pretty straightforward to add by the means of a simple “contains samples” relationship or should I add the actual speech too?
The other sample I’ve identified is audio only but since it’s from a movie by a character that’s actually also a real person I’m not sure if the “contains samples” relationship should be related to the (voice) actor or the person portrayed (or a “fake” character)
See also
- Edit 85267982 (concerning an audio sample of a real character)
- Credited as for opera / theatre
Case 3 involves Trump again (I can see you rolling your eyes )
Probably not a hard one but I’m curious if people think it’s bullshit before I add more of them.
If you watch the entire video you’ll notice a couple more “appearances” (face swaps). Those I don’t plan to add, only the original ones.