The last time Derwin was proposed for autoeditor was almost 10 years ago!
and it was also by me, heh.
Back then it was probably too early, but today is another story!
derwin/darwin edits in predominantly electronic, dj/house music, and looking at his stats Editor “darwinx0r” - MusicBrainz he has few downvoted edits.
He’s been an editor for over 10 years now and is active on irc and will happily discuss edits with anyone.
Votes are a bit low, but I’m sure we can encourage him to vote more (heavens knows I could vote more myself! ;))
I don’t think import scripts need extra edit notes, as long as it includes the source which is what I’d expect in a manual edit note anyway
The only reason I would no vote is because of the lack of edit notes on some edits, but upon closer inspection these edits are either self-explanatory or are edits made by darwinx0r to a release they had recently imported themselves. So I wouldn’t expect an ‘oops’ comment on every one (I am also in this situation often : P). I usually look at edit history in the context of edits on an artist or release, not a user, so this works for me.
It’s their openness to feedback and regular discussion on IRC that swings it for me, valuable and flexible contributor