Why does this match?

I’m stumped … why does Picard 3.0 consider this a match when I hit “Lookup”?

The actual release is apparently not in the database, but the track in question and the “match” have absolutely nothing in common, except for two words in the title and the track number. The track length even differs by more than an hour! :thinking:

Logs please ideally with relevant options like “Matching”:

D: 21:51:18,535 picard\ui\mainwindow.set_statusbar_message:772: Looking up the metadata for file \\storage-ge-1\media\TEMP\Audio\TEST\01 Mood Music (For Mood Swings).mp3 …
D: 21:51:19,786 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Pop Smoke": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,786 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,786 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Lil Tjay": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,787 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,788 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "A Boogie Wit da Hoodie": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,788 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,789 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Burnz": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,789 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,789 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Mike Stern": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,790 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,790 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Jaco Pastorius": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,790 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,790 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Adam Nussbaum": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,790 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,790 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Steve Slagle": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,790 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,791 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "DJ Entropy": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,791 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,791 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Lenii": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,791 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,791 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Tove Styrke": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,792 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,792 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "PlayThatBoiZay": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,792 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,792 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Mike Dimes": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,792 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,793 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Henry Moodie": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,793 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,793 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "New Dialogue": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,793 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Travy Dev": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Angelo Reeves": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "OH!DULCEARi": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Carzé": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,794 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,795 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Ignite": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,795 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,795 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Lamin": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,795 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,795 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Micheal Williams": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,795 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,796 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Ava Maybee": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,796 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,796 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Gert Blokzijl": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,796 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,797 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "CThruRio": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,797 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,797 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "A Boogie Wit da Hoodie": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,797 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,798 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "EVAN GIIA": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,798 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,798 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Josh A": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,798 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,799 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Oldone": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,799 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,799 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Hanz": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,799 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,799 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Hollyn": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,799 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,800 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Little Simz": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,800 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,800 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Jaco Pastorius": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,800 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,801 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Paddy Thorne": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,801 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,801 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Sophie Pecora": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,801 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,801 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Files J": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,801 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,802 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Robert D": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,802 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,802 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Marcus King": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,802 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,803 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Qasebillo": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,803 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,803 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Nova Twins": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,803 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,803 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "220 BPM Junkie": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,804 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,804 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Why T": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,804 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,804 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Upserver": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,804 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,804 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Upserver": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,805 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,805 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Tangent Quartet": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,805 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,805 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Scotty Sire": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,805 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,806 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Swindle": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,806 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,806 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Upserver": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,806 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,806 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Mercury Rev": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,807 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,807 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Gomey": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,807 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,807 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Alley Cats": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,807 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,808 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Little Simz": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,808 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,808 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Swindle": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,808 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,809 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Tim Louis": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,809 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,809 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Little Simz": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,809 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,809 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Laughta": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,810 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,810 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Mario": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,810 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,810 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Isabel Wood": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,810 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,811 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "C‐Rayz Walz": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,811 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,811 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "The Wolverton Brothers": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,811 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\mbjson._log_detected_scripts:511: Script alpha characters found in "Robot Needs Oil": LATIN (100.0%)
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\mbjson._log_selected_scripts_match:553: Match found in selected scripts: LATIN (60%); CYRILLIC (80%)
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\file._match_to_track:1251: [matching] match_to_track: file='\\\\storage-ge-1\\media\\TEMP\\Audio\\TEST\\01 Mood Music (For Mood Swings).mp3', 50 candidates, min_sim=0.250, min_margin=0.020
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\file._match_to_track:1258: [matching]   file meta: title='Mood Music (For Mood Swings)' artist='Radiolab' tracknumber='1' length=1072013
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\file._match_to_track:1266: [matching]   prefs: countries=['DE', 'XE', 'NL', 'XW'] formats=['Digital Media', 'CD', '12" Vinyl', '7" Vinyl'] types=['Album'] discouraged=['Compilation', 'DJ-mix', 'Mixtape/Street', 'Single', 'Soundtrack']
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #1 sim=0.4211 = base 0.4342 x score 0.97  'Mood swings' (78d92f7f-9b11-43a6-89d8-623f7f8edd0b)
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #2 sim=0.4198 = base 0.4466 x score 0.94  'Mood Swings' (a6312db1-c8ae-4c4c-a809-4ac060907ae0)
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #3 sim=0.3836 = base 0.4081 x score 0.94  'Mood Swings' (34ced048-094e-4714-9b04-f2e963b08574)
D: 21:51:19,812 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #4 sim=0.3774 = base 0.3774 x score 1.00  'Mood Swings' (05169358-3ad1-4192-bb0e-b46d571b0213)
D: 21:51:19,813 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #5 sim=0.3647 = base 0.3760 x score 0.97  'Mood Swings' (fe572113-495c-48aa-a2c1-43fcdf60195c)
D: 21:51:19,813 picard\file._match_to_track:1296: [matching]   AMBIGUOUS: best=0.4211
D: 21:51:19,813 picard\ui\mainwindow.set_statusbar_message:772: Best match for file "\\storage-ge-1\media\TEMP\Audio\TEST\01 Mood Music (For Mood Swings).mp3" is ambiguous
D: 21:51:19,813 picard\tagger.load_album:1213: Album 8621fb47-f58b-45a8-888b-404ed8779b26 already loaded.
D: 21:51:19,813 picard\file.move:911: Moving <MP3File '01 Mood Music (For Mood Swings).mp3'> from <Cluster 'Unclustered Files'> to <Track 78d92f7f-9b11-43a6-89d8-623f7f8edd0b 'Mood swings'>

(Written before the logs were posted.)

Because it found at least one match > 25% and gave you the best one.

25% seems to me to be a very low minimum match value. Is this the default or has the user lowered it?

But I suspect that the matching algorithm is also making mistakes here.

Radiolab isn’t an artist in the database, and I suspect that the scoring is different when comparing a potential match between 1) the original artist exists and the artist MBIDs don’t match, and 2) the original artist doesn’t exist.

IMO these non-matching values should both contribute equally negatively to the scoring but perhaps (and I haven’t checked the code) if the original artist isn’t found it simply ignores the field completely (effectively giving higher weights to the other fields) rather than giving it a negative score for a mismatch. And if this is the case, then Radiolabs not existing as an artist in MBID, it would result in a greater weight given to the partial match on the Track Title (which is where this track seems to have been successfully matched.

EDIT: I see that the logs end by it saying that the “Best match … is ambiguous”

I am not sure what exactly this means when it comes to the scoring algorithm, but the similarity scores are all VERY close (0.3647-0.4211) and this may be why.

But assuming that the similarity scores can take values of 0.0000-1.0000 a score of c. 0.4 seems to be very high for such a poor match - and definitely higher than the 0.2500 minimum match value, so it selected the highest of the scores as a match.

TL;DR - Scores of c. 0.4 for such a poor match suggest that the algorithm might need looking at and if the default minimum score is 25% then I would suggest that this should probably be set higher.

Yes, 25% is the default. The only change I made was to increase the track duration difference from 2 to 3 seconds.

I tried and changed the artist from “Radiolab” to “Radiohead”, who are in the database, and it gave me the same match, even with a slightly higher similarity of 0.4260.

D: 22:16:17,650 picard\file._match_to_track:1251: [matching] match_to_track: file='\\\\storage-ge-1\\media\\TEMP\\Audio\\TEST\\01 Mood Music (For Mood Swings).mp3', 50 candidates, min_sim=0.250, min_margin=0.020
D: 22:16:17,650 picard\file._match_to_track:1258: [matching]   file meta: title='Mood Music (For Mood Swings)' artist='Radiohead' tracknumber='1' length=1072013
D: 22:16:17,650 picard\file._match_to_track:1266: [matching]   prefs: countries=['DE', 'XE', 'NL', 'XW'] formats=['Digital Media', 'CD', '12" Vinyl', '7" Vinyl'] types=['Album'] discouraged=['Compilation', 'DJ-mix', 'Mixtape/Street', 'Single', 'Soundtrack']
D: 22:16:17,650 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #1 sim=0.4260 = base 0.4392 x score 0.97  'Mood swings' (78d92f7f-9b11-43a6-89d8-623f7f8edd0b)
D: 22:16:17,650 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #2 sim=0.4188 = base 0.4456 x score 0.94  'Mood Swings' (a6312db1-c8ae-4c4c-a809-4ac060907ae0)
D: 22:16:17,650 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #3 sim=0.3775 = base 0.4016 x score 0.94  'Mood Swings' (34ced048-094e-4714-9b04-f2e963b08574)
D: 22:16:17,651 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #4 sim=0.3767 = base 0.3767 x score 1.00  'Mood Swings' (05169358-3ad1-4192-bb0e-b46d571b0213)
D: 22:16:17,651 picard\file._match_to_track:1279: [matching]   #5 sim=0.3690 = base 0.3804 x score 0.97  'Mood Swings' (fe572113-495c-48aa-a2c1-43fcdf60195c)
D: 22:16:17,651 picard\file._match_to_track:1296: [matching]   AMBIGUOUS: best=0.4260

Looking at the options again, I would have thought that the third option “Minimal similarity for matching files to tracks”, which defaults to 40%, is the relevant value here. But even if I set that to 100%, it still comes up with the same result. Setting the first one to 43% prevents the match, though.

I would still like to understand where the 42% similarity come from.

I have some historical experience of designing a complex weighted search algorithm (a bugger to debug but delivered excellent results - way better than the predecessor system (and when I revisited the client several years later, they had replaced the system again and NOT duplicated the search engine so mine was also way better than the successor system).

However, I have never got to grips with how the Picard search engine works, and so either Zas or Phillip will need to take a look.

The matching is indeed a bit of a mystery.

D: 14:57:07,360 picard\cluster._match_to_release:423: [matching] match_to_release: cluster='Porno Poesie', 50 candidates, min_sim=0.250, min_margin=0.020
D: 14:57:07,360 picard\cluster._match_to_release:430: [matching]   cluster meta: album='Porno Poesie' albumartist='LD Crew feat. Alive' date='2016' totaltracks='12' barcode='' catno=''
D: 14:57:07,360 picard\cluster._match_to_release:440: [matching]   prefs: countries=[] formats=[] types=[] discouraged=[]
D: 14:57:07,361 picard\cluster._match_to_release:453: [matching]   #1 sim=0.4691 = base 0.5721 x score 0.82  'Métropolitaine Poésie' (b8bd41ca-92a1-4a04-ae4e-44428a8bf9b5)
D: 14:57:07,361 picard\cluster._match_to_release:453: [matching]   #2 sim=0.4040 = base 0.5114 x score 0.79  'Porno.' (9109dc18-6af4-46da-816a-412f766c1991)
D: 14:57:07,361 picard\cluster._match_to_release:453: [matching]   #3 sim=0.3754 = base 0.3754 x score 1.00  'Geld & Frauen Mixtape' (1ab61662-4998-4810-9860-a8117e8cf38c)
D: 14:57:07,361 picard\cluster._match_to_release:453: [matching]   #4 sim=0.3604 = base 0.5300 x score 0.68  'Porno' (f396aa3d-7d4b-4720-b234-234ec9d67b1d)
D: 14:57:07,361 picard\cluster._match_to_release:453: [matching]   #5 sim=0.3488 = base 0.5129 x score 0.68  'Porno' (d0238228-42ad-4f17-bdeb-61fb8bf14c36)
D: 14:57:07,361 picard\ui\mainwindow.set_statusbar_message:772: Cluster Porno Poesie identified!
D: 14:57:07,362 picard\ui\mainwindow.set_statusbar_message:772: Loading album b8bd41ca-92a1-4a04-ae4e-44428a8bf9b5 …

2 Likes

Very interesting read about the matching algorithm. I’ll have to let that sink in a bit.

And thanks for the fix!