A Bootleg that is new recordings from concert, OK, or a pirate version of albums, well ok also, I think.
But here is like a home made compilation of random existing studio tracks.
It still sounds as playlist (series or collection?) to me.
I didn’t add my homemade compilations to MB. Even if I shared some of them with friends and family.
I made an online payable best playlist also, long time ago (with a tool called radio.blog.club).
My playlist content almost never changed (which is main problem of digital compilations), but I would not add it as a MusicBrainz release. I would feel like adding unnecessary noise.
I didn’t think in terms of difference in what I add to MB compared to… you or to that release adder?
I don’t know if there is a difference.
The only difference I could imagine maybe is that I mostly edit physical release, is that what you meant?
I was not trying to judge the style in any way, I didn’t really have a look at the content, yet.
I know understood it is about a festival setlist.
So rather than release, series or collection, it could have been just an MB event.
But far from me the idea of removing that release!
I have made some release edits which the original submitter has voted against and I would appreciate some thoughts from the wider community. In my opinion the label has submitted very poor quality metadata, resulting in confusing/inaccurate artist credits on every digital store and streaming site.
I included a reasonably detailed justification in my note for edit #100286847, which is essentially that the release blurb (see Traxsource / Beatport / Special Requests) is a more accurate source for the artist credits than the metadata submitted with the release. I’m not a digital metadata “literalist” and would prefer that the releases in MB are accurate (on the balance of probabilities) rather than just replicating errors from other sources, however I know this not a view shared by everyone.
You know when you are adding a heap of singles… adding lots of credits… lots of browser tabs open. And then you realise you have just put all the credits for Release A onto Release B because you had the swapped back to the wrong tab? Yeah… I just did that. Doh!
A pile of votes to wipe this out will be nice thanks:
Edited to add: Thanks… lets see if it now goes away a bit quicker.
Just realized that you got 5 yes-votes already, thus mine would be obsolete. Now you’ll have to wait for 48 hours only
PS: hope you checked the recordings
Edit: Sorry, should have checked your profile before giving superfluous advices.