Two recordings with same AcoustID are not necessarily equal

Can someone please fix https://musicbrainz.org/doc/How_To_Merge_Recordings?

It says:

Two recordings are considered equal, if their “acoustic content” is the same.

Which is wrong, as I said in AI recording merge userscript comment, because AcoustID only scans the first 2 (and previously less) minutes of recordings.

Acoustic content ≠ AcoustID

1 Like

Ah ok good!
Because that script comment was talking a lot about AcoustID, I got mistaken.

I may be wrong, but I thought an AcoustID of a ten minute track is different to the AcoustID of the 5 minute edit as that length is taken into account. The fingerprint may only be of the same first two minutes of both tracks, but I thought the length came into the maths somewhere.

Or I may be wrong…

3 Likes

Yes, duration counts but, if two 5 minutes recordings have common 2 minute intro but then different mix (like backing tracks only or like some overdubs), they will have same AcoustID.

3 Likes

Is it worth putting a little note after the sentence quoted by @jesus2099 or elsewhere in the guide that AcoustID isn’t infallible? Something like:

Be aware that due to technical limitations, two recordings with the same start and length may have the same AcoustID, even if the middle or end of the recordings are different - so be careful when merging.

(edit: OK I see the AcoustID guide explains this, but only after a lot of useful but technical explanation so perhaps good to stil touch on this in the How to Merge guidance)

1 Like