I’d like to clarify if recordings should be separated when there’s ~10s difference in split points.
Style / Recording - MusicBrainz is not really clear about this but I would put this into the mastering differences family of pro-merge criteria and assume that artists wouldn’t support the idea of separate recordings in a case like this.
An additional advantage is that we wouldn’t have to guess which recordings to use for poorly documented releases or even introduce further recordings for any inbetween cases.
The initial discussions are spread across several edits:
I’ve been splitting this when it is obvious that there is segue between two songs and the transition point is before the segue on some releases and after on others. That is a pretty significant different in the content of each recording. But, I get that it is a mastering decision/error and the band probably never cared about them being listened to seperately so may not even have a preference. Of course there are cases where the segue is split at more than just the two ends which makes things really difficult. For me it is a matter of how different the listening experience is as to whether I would want them to be separate. Very subjective, I know.
2 Likes