Provide more User Submitted Data with AcoustId


#1

AcoustID has 45M unique ids, MusicBrainz has 20M so there are roughly 25M recordings in AcoustID that can not be matched to MusicBrainz, and this disparity looks set to increase over time.

So for these songs the metadata submitted when a fingerprint is added to AcoustId becomes more important. Although this data has to be used carefully as there is no 3rd party verification it can be used to provide some basic identification of songs.

AcoustId currently returns:

  • Artist
  • Title
  • Album

if they were submitted with the fingerprint

But could this be extended with two common fields that would be found in alot of user submitted metadata, trackno and albumArtist.

If AcoustId returned TrackNo then we could construct basic album metadata for a group of songs that could only be matched to AcoustId.

If AcoustId returned AlbumArtist, this would be very helpful for identifying if the album is a various artists compilation release.


#2

And track length…


#3

Track length is shown already (see under Fingerprints) , but its not part of user submitted metadata its a property of the track itself


#4

Length is next to all fingerprints but not next to all track name / artist / album name, in the bottom of the page.
So we don’t know this/that track time is for this/that album track.


#5

That is just a website display issue the api does return the duration relating to a particular dataset.