Mountain cave as a 'place' entity

In this release there is a next relationship:

We hiked to a mountain cave in Switzerland to sing Skyrim songs. This is our arrangement of the original soundtrack by Jeremy Soule.

A mountain cave doesn’t conflict with the place guidelines:

A place is a building or outdoor area used for performing or producing music.

which means it can be added like that. But I never saw uses of this kind, so wanted to ask if I did everything correctly:


1 Like

overall it looks decent, tho I do have a few minor issues with it

first, I would follow the [unknown] guidelines and put the caves’ name in [brackets], i.e. [mountain cave in Switzerland] or so

on that note, I probably would have created a place for that specific cave, not for all the caves in Switzerland. might make it a bit tricky since we don’t know the name (as mentioned above), but that’s preferable to what’s currently entered, in my mind. I wouldn’t create a worldwide place for all the caves of the world for similar reasons

apart from that tho, it looks good to me~

2 Likes

I would use the [unknown] location, credited as mountain cave in Switzerland.
Because, as nobody know what cave it is, we will never be able to add a second relationship to this place.
So it’s better to not have a place for only one relationship.

4 Likes

I guess potentially someone could ask the choir what cave this was - to be honest, I suspect many people from Switzerland with an interest in caves could tell from the video alone.

2 Likes

Swiss here, confirming that I can tell which cave just from the acoustics in the recording.

6 Likes