Handling label acquisitions

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007f0eb34674e0> #<Tag:0x00007f0eb34671e8>

Recently, Monstercat acquired Silk Music, and the 2 labels have been merged into one, with Silk Music becoming Monstercat’s “Monstercat Silk” brand (alongside the existing “Monstercat Uncaged” and “Monstercat Instinct”). How should this event be handled in MusicBrainz? Should the 2 labels remain separate, or should they be merged? As for the releases, should “re-releases” be made under their release groups, or should they be moved?

It’s a bit of an exceptional situation, so I just want to clarify how this should be represented in MusicBrainz before making any changes.

1 Like

I would make a new label, and keep crediting all releases according to the information on the release itself.

4 Likes

Does anything need to be done for the old releases (eg. new release)? Or do they just stay on the old label?

They would stay on the old label. If a release is re-released on the new label, you can add the new release with the new label in the same release group.

3 Likes

Hmm, I’m not 100% sure what would constitute a release in this situation. Both labels rarely have physical releases, and mostly distribute digital media. As an example, take Kaiyan - Apollo 11, a release from Silk Music before the acquisition and merger, that now appears on Monstercat’s official website. The page linked shows a release date of 6/1/2021, which was the date it was released on Silk Music, but it only appeared in Monstercat’s catalog on 22/3/2021 (the same date as all other pre-acquisition releases). Does this constitute a new release, and if so, which is the correct release date?

We thought you were about physical releases.
For physical releases, you keep the printed label.
For download releases, I have no opinion, but I’m tagging this topic now. :wink:

With digital releases I would do the same as with physical ones, it’s just more difficult to find out the truth.

Please add an annotation to the labels explaining that release dates before the merger should be credited to one of the two pre-merge entities.

5 Likes

Ok, so all Silk Music releases before the merge remain on Silk Music, but Silk releases after the merge go to Monstercat? If so, I’ll add an annotation to both labels noting that. Thanks for the help!

1 Like

If I understand correctly, this seems like the right occasion to put an End Date on the old label. Yes?
https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Label#Date_period

2 Likes