Hello everybody.
I try to submit discid for this release via Picard
no problem for the first disc but MB don’t propose me the second disc
What i’m doing wrong ?
1 Like
Are you sure you are trying to submit the correct discid, first disc has 18 tracks, second has 17 tracks?
Try with the other disc.
In fact the second disc has 18 tracks as well. I have an edit to correct that in pending. This could be the problem ?
The release https://musicbrainz.org/release/0b1a42ba-2bac-4735-ada4-071b282f4ffa has 2 CDs 18 + 17 tracks, so your release differs (or the existing release is incorrect).
Check track titles & durations on both your physical release and the one in MB.
1 Like
The existing release is incorrect (cf: discogs, amazon, bnf). I’ll wait for my edit to be validate to resubmit the discid. Thanks for the feedback.
You think that Power Rock: 35 Rock Classics didn’t exist?
I don’t think you can repurpose it to Power Rock: 36 classiques du rock.
Why don’t you add your French edition with one additional track besides the English edition with one track less, instead?
2 Likes
Looking at https://www.discogs.com/release/12762265-Various-Power-Rock/image/SW1hZ2U6MzY5ODYyMzI= it lists 36 tracks (2x18) though the front cover show “35” and the CD image shows 36… so something is weird.
@Courtequeue you’d better create a new release and provide all details from the actual physical CD you have in hands, as suggested by @jesus2099, it is much better, especially if you are able to provide cover art along discids.
I would not rely on the existing release.
4 Likes
I would say the title is the biggest hint it is a different edition. Yeah there are often errors on track lists, but sticking “35” in the name makes me think you have a different edition for France with 36 tracks.
1 Like
Even on my french edition the cd case show 35 
Notice how the Amazon link shows 36?
https://www.amazon.fr/gp/product/B00004UU64?tag=music083d-21
Is your copy possibly second hand? I’ve had cases swapped on me before on a second hand market.
It was a first hand copy. The booklet show 36 and the cd case 35. With the same design.