Band "Betalmand" lost without trace

Hi

The old entry for the band Betalmand is gone, I was wondering what happened.

https://musicbrainz.org/artist/05a4a17d-2035-4174-af4d-5e5a7bc8977b

The band has multiple setlists on setlist.fm, edits from 2018 to 2026:

https://www.setlist.fm/setlists/betalmand-23c92893.html

I tried the edit search, but searching for Betalmand only lets me choose the new entry, and searching for ID i’mgetting the error that only numbers can be entered.

How can I solve this?

btw, the new entry for the band is brand new, not merged.

If an artist page is entirely empty (i.e. no releases, no events, no other relationships) it is automatically removed after a while.

You need to link it to at least one other MB entity. The new page should be safe, since it has some URLs attached.

If the page existed for quite a while and then it was gone, it is possible that only one link was added and it was eventually removed (because it broke?). Adding their album should ensure they do not get removed even if all links were to break in the future.

Alright, thanks. Don’t know how “complete” the entry was.
Also, I’m a fan of keeping outdated links and just set them to “ended”, might help for research, i.e. on wayback machine.
But are there logs that show the deletion? How do I access them?

@Bitmap made a direct database search and saw that the band was originally deleted (because it was empty) back in 2018 (Edit #58306310 - MusicBrainz - so long ago we didn’t even have any proper message explaining the removal yet).

I am not sure, to be honest, about how to associate the existing setlist.fm entry with the new band - you might need to get in touch with their own support team.

Thanks, @Bitmap !
So setlist.fm seems to keep old entries usable, since it was last used in 2026.
And I saw someone re-link another band a few days ago, so that seems to work.

btw, the band was deleted roughly one week after someone made the first setlist, so an empty entry is very likely.

Solved.

1 Like

I assume this is the same band? https://www.discogs.com/artist/4294860-Betalmand

Attach that Discogs link to the new version when you add it. Add their Facebook, Bandcamp, Homepage. The more links the better.

Yes, it’s them. I already scraped all links from their Metal Archives entry.

I’ve added a redirect for the old MBID 05a4a17d-2035-4174-af4d-5e5a7bc8977b to the new one, but not sure if that will affect setlist.fm.

5 Likes